WEBVTT FILE

1
00:00:02.000 --> 00:00:07.000
Downloaded from
YTS.BZ

2
00:00:08.000 --> 00:00:13.000
Official YIFY movies site:
YTS.BZ

3
00:00:19.367 --> 00:00:20.585
Ahem.

4
00:00:23.414 --> 00:00:25.547
I remember everything.

5
00:00:28.158 --> 00:00:29.464
I said...

6
00:00:29.551 --> 00:00:31.509
"Could I have hit him?

7
00:00:31.553 --> 00:00:33.381
Did I hit him?"

8
00:00:36.775 --> 00:00:38.908
And I'm not as clear
as if I hadn't been drinking.

9
00:00:59.494 --> 00:01:01.061
Hey, can I get a vodka soda?

10
00:01:05.848 --> 00:01:07.110
Did it start snowing yet?

11
00:01:07.197 --> 00:01:08.416
No, not yet.

12
00:01:11.506 --> 00:01:13.116
You know, my dad said

13
00:01:13.160 --> 00:01:15.988
I shouldn't be out
with a blizzard on the way.

14
00:01:16.032 --> 00:01:17.077
Yeah, your dad's
probably right.

15
00:01:18.513 --> 00:01:19.949
But, hey...

16
00:01:19.992 --> 00:01:21.733
I'm glad you came.

17
00:01:26.477 --> 00:01:28.044
Hey.

18
00:01:42.667 --> 00:01:43.799
Uh, Chris Albert.

19
00:01:43.842 --> 00:01:45.322
-And?
-A bunch of them

20
00:01:45.366 --> 00:01:47.281
down by the Waterfall,
he says.

21
00:01:48.456 --> 00:01:49.544
Do you wanna go?

22
00:01:51.763 --> 00:01:53.591
Or we could just go
back to your place.

23
00:01:55.419 --> 00:01:57.769
Look, it'll be easier
to go by, have a drink,

24
00:01:57.856 --> 00:01:58.814
than come up with some excuse.

25
00:02:00.903 --> 00:02:02.034
-Okay, let's go.
-Yeah, we're going?

26
00:02:02.078 --> 00:02:03.471
-Yeah, let's go.
-Take your bag.

27
00:02:20.879 --> 00:02:22.664
Hey! Saint John!

28
00:02:22.751 --> 00:02:24.231
-Johnny!
-Hey!

29
00:02:24.318 --> 00:02:25.580
Hey!

30
00:02:25.667 --> 00:02:26.755
-You!
-Hi!

31
00:02:26.798 --> 00:02:27.886
Hey, Karen.

32
00:02:27.930 --> 00:02:30.019
Who invited these losers?

33
00:02:30.106 --> 00:02:31.586
-Come on over.
-Uh, blame your brother.

34
00:02:31.673 --> 00:02:33.588
-Hey.
-What're you pricks drinking?

35
00:02:33.631 --> 00:02:34.632
Whatever you pricks are buying.

36
00:02:34.719 --> 00:02:36.286
-Oh!
-You kiss that mouth?

37
00:02:36.373 --> 00:02:38.158
Best way I know
to shut her up.

38
00:02:38.201 --> 00:02:39.115
-Hey!
-Hey.

39
00:02:39.159 --> 00:02:40.595
Come on.

40
00:02:40.638 --> 00:02:42.249
Uh...

41
00:02:42.379 --> 00:02:44.076
-Gather around.
-You in?

42
00:02:44.164 --> 00:02:45.034
Cheers!

43
00:02:45.077 --> 00:02:47.471
Cheers.

44
00:02:49.430 --> 00:02:51.606
I'm really glad
I came tonight.

45
00:02:51.649 --> 00:02:53.608
-Cheers.
-Cheers.

46
00:02:53.651 --> 00:02:55.218
Cheers.

47
00:02:55.305 --> 00:02:57.438
So am I staying at your house
tonight?

48
00:02:57.481 --> 00:02:59.353
I can think of a good reason

49
00:02:59.396 --> 00:03:00.658
you might want
to stay at my place tonight.

50
00:03:02.225 --> 00:03:03.139
Do another drink, huh?

51
00:03:04.619 --> 00:03:06.621
Come to my place.

52
00:03:06.664 --> 00:03:07.883
Last call!

53
00:03:13.715 --> 00:03:15.369
Let's keep this party going!

54
00:03:15.412 --> 00:03:16.631
Let's all go back to my place.

55
00:03:16.674 --> 00:03:17.632
-Here we go!
-All right.

56
00:03:17.719 --> 00:03:18.894
-Whoo!
-Good plan.

57
00:03:18.937 --> 00:03:20.156
Make sure you let
those guys know, yeah?

58
00:03:20.200 --> 00:03:21.418
Yeah, yeah, I will.
I'll let 'em know.

59
00:03:21.462 --> 00:03:22.593
We're all going back
to Brian's place.

60
00:03:22.680 --> 00:03:23.855
You coming?

61
00:03:23.899 --> 00:03:26.206
Uh... yeah. Yeah!

62
00:03:26.249 --> 00:03:28.208
Great. It's at Fairview,
but I'll text you.

63
00:03:30.384 --> 00:03:31.646
Really?

64
00:03:31.733 --> 00:03:33.082
It's after midnight.

65
00:03:33.213 --> 00:03:34.388
Can't we just go back
to your house,

66
00:03:34.431 --> 00:03:35.563
just you and me?

67
00:03:35.693 --> 00:03:37.695
One drink.
Come on, we'll be a minute!

68
00:03:37.739 --> 00:03:38.479
All right.

69
00:03:38.522 --> 00:03:40.872
Mm.

70
00:03:40.916 --> 00:03:43.179
Mm! Good stuff.

71
00:03:44.311 --> 00:03:45.529
Hey!

72
00:03:48.880 --> 00:03:50.534
Come on.

73
00:06:03.667 --> 00:06:05.756
Ohh...

74
00:06:15.331 --> 00:06:17.159
John?

75
00:06:32.174 --> 00:06:34.394
John!

76
00:06:48.146 --> 00:06:49.409
John?

77
00:06:54.849 --> 00:06:56.416
John?

78
00:07:03.597 --> 00:07:05.033
John?

79
00:07:16.871 --> 00:07:19.221
This is John. How 'bout you?

80
00:07:19.308 --> 00:07:21.223
John, where the hell are you?

81
00:07:21.266 --> 00:07:22.920
Will you call me back,
please?

82
00:07:22.920 --> 00:07:24.444
Call me.

83
00:07:27.925 --> 00:07:29.144
John, where the hell are you?

84
00:07:31.015 --> 00:07:32.452
Pick up the phone,
goddammit!

85
00:07:34.932 --> 00:07:35.803
Jen!

86
00:07:36.978 --> 00:07:39.328
Karen? What's going on?

87
00:07:39.371 --> 00:07:40.590
I don't know where John is!

88
00:07:40.677 --> 00:07:42.026
What? Wh-What do you mean?

89
00:07:42.113 --> 00:07:43.027
I can't find him.
Have you-- Have you--

90
00:07:43.114 --> 00:07:44.464
Have you talked to him,

91
00:07:44.507 --> 00:07:45.595
or have you seen him?

92
00:07:45.639 --> 00:07:47.379
-Just calm down.
-He-He's not here.

93
00:07:47.423 --> 00:07:48.424
-Tell me what happened.
-
He never came home last night

94
00:07:48.468 --> 00:07:50.470
and I'm totally freaking out
right now!

95
00:07:50.513 --> 00:07:51.732
I mean, I figured
you guys just...

96
00:07:51.775 --> 00:07:52.994
He never came home.

97
00:07:53.037 --> 00:07:54.169
I don't know what to do,

98
00:07:54.256 --> 00:07:54.952
I'm seriously
freaking out over here.

99
00:07:55.039 --> 00:07:56.388
Jen, he never came home!

100
00:07:56.432 --> 00:07:58.390
Just relax, okay?
I'm sure he's fine.

101
00:07:58.434 --> 00:08:00.305
W-We'll figure it out, okay?

102
00:08:00.349 --> 00:08:01.393
I think I just need
to go look for him.

103
00:08:01.481 --> 00:08:02.743
I can't just stand here!

104
00:08:02.830 --> 00:08:03.657
I have to go!

105
00:08:11.447 --> 00:08:12.492
Oh, shit.

106
00:08:30.684 --> 00:08:32.076
Pick up, John!

107
00:08:32.120 --> 00:08:33.338
Pick up the phone,
goddammit!

108
00:08:35.950 --> 00:08:37.342
Pick up the phone!

109
00:08:40.432 --> 00:08:42.217
Kerry, I'm worried.

110
00:08:42.304 --> 00:08:43.958
I'm worried
John might be dead.

111
00:08:44.001 --> 00:08:45.394
What?

112
00:08:45.481 --> 00:08:46.874
I think he may have
gotten hit by a plow.

113
00:08:46.917 --> 00:08:48.353
He never came home last night.

114
00:08:48.397 --> 00:08:50.355
We were all out drinking,
and--

115
00:08:50.399 --> 00:08:53.054
Well, Karen, maybe
you shouldn't be on the road.

116
00:08:53.141 --> 00:08:54.795
No, I'm headed
to Jen McCabe's.

117
00:08:54.838 --> 00:08:56.666
Will you help us, please?
Will you come?

118
00:08:56.753 --> 00:08:58.625
Please, will you come help us?

119
00:09:00.278 --> 00:09:01.845
Let's meet back at John's.

120
00:09:07.851 --> 00:09:09.157
Jen?

121
00:09:09.200 --> 00:09:11.551
Jen! Jen, get in the car.

122
00:09:11.594 --> 00:09:12.769
Kerry's meeting us
back at John's house.

123
00:09:12.813 --> 00:09:14.510
What happened here?

124
00:09:14.597 --> 00:09:16.425
I backed up into John's car
as I was-- I was pulling out.

125
00:09:16.468 --> 00:09:17.600
Maybe he's at home.

126
00:09:17.644 --> 00:09:18.688
Maybe we'll just check
the house again.

127
00:09:18.732 --> 00:09:20.124
No, I have checked
the entire house!

128
00:09:20.168 --> 00:09:21.169
-Every room!
-Okay--

129
00:09:21.169 --> 00:09:23.171
And I've been calling him.

130
00:09:23.258 --> 00:09:25.652
-Okay, let's just look again!
-Just get in the car!

131
00:09:25.695 --> 00:09:26.914
It's okay!

132
00:09:42.190 --> 00:09:45.062
I told you he wasn't here.

133
00:09:45.149 --> 00:09:48.152
I don't know, maybe he--
he-he...

134
00:09:48.196 --> 00:09:49.676
he went and slept it off
at the Alberts'?

135
00:09:49.719 --> 00:09:51.025
And maybe he-he was too drunk?

136
00:09:51.112 --> 00:09:52.896
-I mean, we didn't see him.
-Can we just--

137
00:09:53.027 --> 00:09:54.332
Can we please just go there?

138
00:09:54.376 --> 00:09:56.421
Do you remember
where you last saw him?

139
00:09:56.465 --> 00:09:58.859
No, I don't--
I don't know. I mean...

140
00:09:58.946 --> 00:10:00.643
I don't know.

141
00:10:00.687 --> 00:10:02.123
Uh, I saw you guys pull up
in front of Brian's.

142
00:10:03.559 --> 00:10:04.865
What?

143
00:10:04.908 --> 00:10:06.475
Yeah,
I saw your car out front.

144
00:10:06.518 --> 00:10:08.129
I mean, I figured you guys
changed your mind and left.

145
00:10:09.434 --> 00:10:10.958
No, I...

146
00:10:11.045 --> 00:10:12.873
No, I-I...

147
00:10:12.960 --> 00:10:14.135
I don't know. I don't--

148
00:10:14.178 --> 00:10:15.527
Maybe. I-I don't know!

149
00:10:15.571 --> 00:10:18.052
Let's just--
just keep driving.

150
00:10:23.405 --> 00:10:25.537
There he is.
There he is!

151
00:10:25.625 --> 00:10:26.495
-What?
-Where?

152
00:10:26.582 --> 00:10:27.409
Stop, stop, stop!

153
00:10:29.759 --> 00:10:30.630
Where are you seeing him?

154
00:10:30.673 --> 00:10:31.413
I'm getting out.

155
00:10:32.980 --> 00:10:33.981
John!

156
00:10:35.504 --> 00:10:37.941
No, no.
No, John!

157
00:10:39.116 --> 00:10:40.988
John!

158
00:10:41.031 --> 00:10:42.250
Oh, my God! No!

159
00:10:42.293 --> 00:10:43.860
No!

160
00:10:43.904 --> 00:10:45.993
John, John, John...

161
00:10:46.036 --> 00:10:47.124
Come on.

162
00:10:47.168 --> 00:10:48.909
No, John! John!

163
00:10:48.952 --> 00:10:50.345
No!

164
00:10:50.432 --> 00:10:51.651
Call 9-1-1!

165
00:10:51.694 --> 00:10:54.741
All right, okay.

166
00:10:54.784 --> 00:10:56.090
- 9-1-1.
- Uh, yeah, yeah.

167
00:10:56.133 --> 00:10:58.788
No, we need someone
to 34 Fairview Road,

168
00:10:58.832 --> 00:11:00.616
-Canton, Mass., now!
-What's going on?

169
00:11:00.703 --> 00:11:02.923
Yeah, there's a guy,
he's unresponsive in the snow!

170
00:11:07.014 --> 00:11:07.754
Come on, John!

171
00:11:11.496 --> 00:11:13.498
Come on, baby...

172
00:11:13.542 --> 00:11:14.543
Come on, baby.

173
00:11:18.329 --> 00:11:20.288
Come on.

174
00:11:31.778 --> 00:11:34.302
No, no, no, no, no.

175
00:11:34.345 --> 00:11:35.738
Hold on.

176
00:11:35.825 --> 00:11:37.044
Jen?

177
00:11:37.087 --> 00:11:38.480
Mike! Oh, my God.

178
00:11:38.567 --> 00:11:39.829
We just found our friend
in the snow!

179
00:11:39.916 --> 00:11:41.483
John O'Keefe.
You know him, right?

180
00:11:41.526 --> 00:11:42.571
-Boston cop?
-Yeah, yeah, yeah.

181
00:11:42.658 --> 00:11:43.877
We don't know
how long he's been here!

182
00:11:49.491 --> 00:11:51.188
Please.

183
00:12:00.328 --> 00:12:03.157
John, please.
Oh, my God.

184
00:12:04.549 --> 00:12:06.508
Yeah, we got
a Boston police officer,

185
00:12:06.551 --> 00:12:08.423
just been found
in the snow here.

186
00:12:09.903 --> 00:12:10.904
Okay... Okay.

187
00:12:10.947 --> 00:12:12.775
No--

188
00:12:12.862 --> 00:12:15.212
Can I get you to step back?
Can I get you to step back?

189
00:12:17.998 --> 00:12:20.217
Uh, he does have
some trauma to his head.

190
00:12:20.261 --> 00:12:22.263
I'm not sure if he was
in a fight or whatever.

191
00:12:22.350 --> 00:12:23.264
-I'm not getting a pulse.
-Okay, all right.

192
00:12:25.483 --> 00:12:26.833
One, two--

193
00:12:26.920 --> 00:12:28.399
He's gonna need an E.R.,
for sure.

194
00:12:28.443 --> 00:12:29.836
EMTs here now.

195
00:12:33.491 --> 00:12:34.971
Can I get in here?

196
00:12:35.015 --> 00:12:36.930
Please, that's my boyfriend!

197
00:12:37.017 --> 00:12:38.714
I-- I left him,
and he never came home.

198
00:12:38.758 --> 00:12:40.760
Please!

199
00:12:40.803 --> 00:12:42.936
Kerry! Jen, is he dead?

200
00:12:42.979 --> 00:12:44.415
He's dead?

201
00:12:47.288 --> 00:12:48.245
He'll be okay.

202
00:12:54.208 --> 00:12:55.687
Dad?

203
00:12:55.731 --> 00:12:57.254
Karen?

204
00:12:57.298 --> 00:12:58.473
It's John.

205
00:12:58.560 --> 00:13:00.127
He's dead.

206
00:13:00.170 --> 00:13:00.910
What?

207
00:13:02.390 --> 00:13:03.957
I don't wanna
be alive right now.

208
00:13:04.000 --> 00:13:06.437
Daddy, I just...

209
00:13:06.524 --> 00:13:09.179
I just wanna die.
This--

210
00:13:09.310 --> 00:13:10.528
Is he breathing?

211
00:13:10.572 --> 00:13:12.095
No.

212
00:13:12.182 --> 00:13:13.488
All right, let's move him!

213
00:13:18.406 --> 00:13:19.581
Wait.

214
00:13:22.149 --> 00:13:23.672
Wait. I...

215
00:13:23.715 --> 00:13:25.108
Canton Control
to Canton 6-8-2.

216
00:13:25.152 --> 00:13:27.458
6-8-2.

217
00:13:27.502 --> 00:13:28.938
Are you aware
of the party on-scene,

218
00:13:29.025 --> 00:13:30.026
or the caller,
named Karen?

219
00:13:30.070 --> 00:13:31.723
Affirmative.

220
00:13:31.811 --> 00:13:33.160
Will he be okay?

221
00:13:33.203 --> 00:13:34.074
I have her father
on the line.

222
00:13:34.117 --> 00:13:35.640
She's making suicidal comments.

223
00:13:37.294 --> 00:13:39.079
I'm gonna Section her,
so we know where she is.

224
00:13:39.166 --> 00:13:41.429
It's okay, John.

225
00:13:41.472 --> 00:13:42.996
John--

226
00:13:43.039 --> 00:13:44.649
Ma'am. Ma'am,
you're gonna be coming with us.

227
00:13:44.693 --> 00:13:46.564
What are you talking about?
I wanna go with him!

228
00:13:46.608 --> 00:13:47.827
They need room to work.

229
00:13:47.914 --> 00:13:49.176
We've got a ride over here
for you.

230
00:13:49.219 --> 00:13:50.873
There's space
in the other ambulance. Please.

231
00:13:50.917 --> 00:13:52.701
-It'll be okay.
-No! I'm going with him.

232
00:13:52.744 --> 00:13:53.702
Please, I'm going with him!

233
00:13:53.789 --> 00:13:55.269
Ma'am--

234
00:13:58.620 --> 00:14:00.187
No!

235
00:14:00.230 --> 00:14:01.188
No!

236
00:14:14.331 --> 00:14:15.463
Oh, God.

237
00:14:17.247 --> 00:14:18.335
Please don't die.

238
00:14:18.379 --> 00:14:20.860
Please don't...

239
00:14:20.903 --> 00:14:22.252
Okay, just try

240
00:14:22.339 --> 00:14:24.211
to focus on trying
to calm your breathing.

241
00:14:26.387 --> 00:14:27.867
I can't--

242
00:14:27.867 --> 00:14:29.825
You don't understand.

243
00:14:31.696 --> 00:14:33.655
I don't wanna live without him.

244
00:14:33.698 --> 00:14:35.135
Ma'am...

245
00:14:35.178 --> 00:14:37.615
are you thinking
about hurting yourself?

246
00:14:41.532 --> 00:14:42.490
Did they find a pulse?

247
00:14:44.274 --> 00:14:46.320
We're on our way
to the hospital.

248
00:14:46.363 --> 00:14:48.235
We're gonna find out more then.

249
00:14:51.716 --> 00:14:53.370
I tried giving him
mouth-to-mouth.

250
00:14:53.414 --> 00:14:55.111
That was good.

251
00:14:55.155 --> 00:14:57.244
And he's going where they can
really take care of him.

252
00:14:57.287 --> 00:14:58.767
He's gonna be there
in a few minutes.

253
00:15:00.987 --> 00:15:03.206
How is this even happening?

254
00:15:03.250 --> 00:15:05.078
Oh, God.

255
00:15:07.036 --> 00:15:08.168
We're right in here.

256
00:15:10.822 --> 00:15:12.563
Why don't you have a seat?

257
00:15:12.607 --> 00:15:14.087
Why am I in here? I--

258
00:15:14.130 --> 00:15:15.001
We just need to run some tests.

259
00:15:15.088 --> 00:15:16.393
I don't understand.

260
00:15:16.437 --> 00:15:17.960
You were brought in
under a "Section 12"--

261
00:15:18.004 --> 00:15:20.049
that's a psychiatric hold.

262
00:15:20.093 --> 00:15:22.269
An EMT's concerned
you might hurt yourself.

263
00:15:22.312 --> 00:15:24.532
I just saw my boyfriend
half-dead in the snow!

264
00:15:24.575 --> 00:15:26.186
I just need to go see him.

265
00:15:26.229 --> 00:15:27.839
Please, let me see him.

266
00:15:27.883 --> 00:15:29.537
Hey, I-I'm looking
for my brother, John O'Keefe.

267
00:15:29.624 --> 00:15:30.930
He was brought in here.

268
00:15:32.366 --> 00:15:33.367
Paul!

269
00:15:33.410 --> 00:15:35.760
Paul... oh.

270
00:15:35.804 --> 00:15:37.893
Paul...

271
00:15:37.937 --> 00:15:39.155
Oh, God.

272
00:15:39.155 --> 00:15:40.374
Paul!

273
00:15:40.417 --> 00:15:42.071
No, that's them. That's my...

274
00:15:42.158 --> 00:15:43.377
That's the family.

275
00:15:43.420 --> 00:15:44.726
Please.
I need to go be with them.

276
00:15:44.769 --> 00:15:46.641
I don't understand.

277
00:15:46.684 --> 00:15:48.860
Why are--
Why are you taking my blood?

278
00:15:48.904 --> 00:15:50.471
Please make a fist.

279
00:15:50.558 --> 00:15:52.168
The doctor will be in soon
to ask you a few questions.

280
00:15:52.255 --> 00:15:53.648
Oh, Jesus.

281
00:16:01.569 --> 00:16:02.962
Hi, Dad.

282
00:16:05.529 --> 00:16:07.836
I got here
as quick as I could.

283
00:16:11.405 --> 00:16:13.320
They won't let me see him.

284
00:16:16.236 --> 00:16:17.977
They, uh...

285
00:16:18.020 --> 00:16:20.588
I mean, honey, they...

286
00:16:20.631 --> 00:16:22.633
they did what they could do.

287
00:16:22.677 --> 00:16:23.939
Did you see him?

288
00:16:23.983 --> 00:16:25.419
Is he okay?

289
00:16:25.506 --> 00:16:27.290
Sweetheart...

290
00:16:30.511 --> 00:16:31.903
...he's, uh...

291
00:16:31.947 --> 00:16:33.470
he's gone.

292
00:16:33.514 --> 00:16:36.082
No.

293
00:16:36.125 --> 00:16:37.648
No!

294
00:16:40.434 --> 00:16:41.478
Please don't tell me that.

295
00:16:41.522 --> 00:16:44.264
No... No, no.

296
00:16:44.351 --> 00:16:46.831
No, he can't be.

297
00:16:46.875 --> 00:16:48.311
They did everything
that could've been done.

298
00:16:53.664 --> 00:16:56.015
How-- How did it happen?

299
00:16:56.058 --> 00:16:58.060
What, I mean... did--

300
00:16:58.104 --> 00:16:59.453
did I hit him?
Did...

301
00:17:01.542 --> 00:17:03.892
Cou-Could I--
Could I have hit him?

302
00:17:20.822 --> 00:17:21.823
John, where are you?

303
00:17:23.694 --> 00:17:26.306
John? Pick up.

304
00:17:26.349 --> 00:17:27.611
Come on! Where are you?

305
00:17:27.655 --> 00:17:30.571
Call me!

306
00:17:30.571 --> 00:17:32.616
John, would you
pick up your phone?

307
00:17:32.660 --> 00:17:34.444
Really?

308
00:17:34.488 --> 00:17:36.229
You're a goddamn loser,
do you know that?

309
00:17:36.272 --> 00:17:38.970
You are a goddamn loser.
Call me back!

310
00:17:39.014 --> 00:17:40.407
I goddamn hate you!

311
00:17:42.365 --> 00:17:43.453
I goddamn hate you!

312
00:17:43.497 --> 00:17:44.672
Do you hear me?

313
00:17:44.759 --> 00:17:46.717
I goddamn hate you!

314
00:18:04.996 --> 00:18:06.476
Proctor,
they put you on this?

315
00:18:06.520 --> 00:18:07.999
Lead investigator.

316
00:18:08.043 --> 00:18:09.827
What are we looking at?

317
00:18:09.871 --> 00:18:11.568
A foot of snow,
and a vague hope

318
00:18:11.612 --> 00:18:13.657
we'll find
anything important underneath.

319
00:18:13.701 --> 00:18:16.312
Why can't these things
only happen in the spring?

320
00:18:16.356 --> 00:18:18.749
What're you doing?
That's a Solo cup.

321
00:18:18.836 --> 00:18:20.273
It's all we got right now.

322
00:18:21.404 --> 00:18:22.449
Just trying to beat
the snowmelt.

323
00:18:34.069 --> 00:18:35.201
How you holding up?

324
00:18:36.506 --> 00:18:38.465
Not good.

325
00:18:40.510 --> 00:18:42.077
How can he be gone?

326
00:18:42.164 --> 00:18:45.124
How can I never,
ever see him again?

327
00:18:47.474 --> 00:18:49.171
I need to see the kids.

328
00:18:49.258 --> 00:18:50.738
Will you take me?

329
00:18:50.825 --> 00:18:52.131
I think that's a good idea.

330
00:19:21.769 --> 00:19:23.771
I wasn't expecting...

331
00:19:30.343 --> 00:19:31.692
I'm so sorry.

332
00:19:40.179 --> 00:19:41.484
Nobody told me

333
00:19:41.484 --> 00:19:44.705
that everybody
was getting together here.

334
00:19:44.748 --> 00:19:48.317
Uh, we all wanted
to be with the kids.

335
00:19:48.361 --> 00:19:50.189
Yeah. Yeah, me too.

336
00:19:51.668 --> 00:19:52.887
How are they?

337
00:19:55.237 --> 00:19:57.979
I mean,
they know what happened.

338
00:19:58.022 --> 00:19:59.372
They're taking it
pretty hard.

339
00:20:01.156 --> 00:20:02.549
Where are they?

340
00:20:02.636 --> 00:20:04.551
Upstairs.

341
00:20:07.336 --> 00:20:08.990
You saw him?

342
00:20:09.033 --> 00:20:11.340
John?

343
00:20:12.689 --> 00:20:15.083
Yeah, I saw him.

344
00:20:15.170 --> 00:20:17.999
They didn't let me see him.

345
00:20:18.042 --> 00:20:20.001
They put me
in a different room.

346
00:20:20.044 --> 00:20:21.785
What did he...

347
00:20:21.829 --> 00:20:24.310
What did he look--
look like?

348
00:20:24.397 --> 00:20:26.225
He was pretty banged up.

349
00:20:27.835 --> 00:20:30.490
Looked to me
like he got hit by a car.

350
00:20:34.276 --> 00:20:35.582
Excuse me.

351
00:20:49.073 --> 00:20:50.727
What the hell is going on here?

352
00:20:50.727 --> 00:20:52.512
They're upset.

353
00:20:52.555 --> 00:20:53.817
I'm upset!

354
00:20:53.861 --> 00:20:56.472
I loved this man.

355
00:20:56.516 --> 00:20:59.867
You know, I spent five nights
a week in this house?

356
00:20:59.910 --> 00:21:01.738
This is more my home
than it is theirs,

357
00:21:01.782 --> 00:21:04.350
and they think
they can just come right in.

358
00:21:04.437 --> 00:21:06.700
Well, you understand
why they want to be here.

359
00:21:08.267 --> 00:21:10.007
And I took care of those kids
like a mother!

360
00:21:10.051 --> 00:21:11.748
I mean, there was...

361
00:21:11.792 --> 00:21:14.795
there was, like,
this bond, you know?

362
00:21:17.580 --> 00:21:20.583
What the hell
is going on here, Dad?

363
00:21:20.670 --> 00:21:22.629
Did you see the way
that they were looking at me?

364
00:21:24.021 --> 00:21:26.546
Everybody's just confused.

365
00:21:26.589 --> 00:21:27.634
Nobody knows what happened.

366
00:21:31.464 --> 00:21:33.161
Neither do I.

367
00:21:34.858 --> 00:21:38.297
But everybody seems
to only be looking at me.

368
00:21:38.340 --> 00:21:40.516
And you know what?

369
00:21:40.560 --> 00:21:43.563
Let them.

370
00:21:43.563 --> 00:21:47.218
Because if I did anything
in any way...

371
00:21:47.306 --> 00:21:48.829
then I will pay my dues.

372
00:21:51.135 --> 00:21:54.008
And this is how it should be.

373
00:21:56.271 --> 00:21:58.621
I want to know the truth, Dad.

374
00:21:58.665 --> 00:22:00.623
Good, bad...

375
00:22:00.710 --> 00:22:02.495
or ugly.

376
00:22:21.427 --> 00:22:22.819
Hi. Mr. Read?

377
00:22:22.950 --> 00:22:24.865
Yes.

378
00:22:24.908 --> 00:22:27.650
I'm Michael Proctor
with Massachusetts State Police.

379
00:22:27.737 --> 00:22:29.696
I understand
your daughter's here?

380
00:22:29.739 --> 00:22:31.306
Come in.

381
00:22:31.350 --> 00:22:33.221
Ahem.

382
00:22:39.270 --> 00:22:40.837
We got
in an argument that day.

383
00:22:40.881 --> 00:22:43.666
It was sort of an ongoing thing.

384
00:22:43.710 --> 00:22:44.885
About what?

385
00:22:44.928 --> 00:22:46.277
Just, you know...

386
00:22:46.321 --> 00:22:48.497
relationship stuff.

387
00:22:48.541 --> 00:22:50.369
Nothing new.

388
00:22:50.499 --> 00:22:52.414
But by the time we met up,
we...

389
00:22:52.501 --> 00:22:55.548
we were all good.

390
00:22:55.591 --> 00:22:59.116
You know, we were--
we were kissing and laughing.

391
00:22:59.160 --> 00:23:01.467
We were with our friends.

392
00:23:01.554 --> 00:23:04.992
And then he got out of the car,
and I left,

393
00:23:05.079 --> 00:23:07.995
and that was-- that was
the last time I ever saw him.

394
00:23:08.082 --> 00:23:10.214
That was outside
the Alberts' house,

395
00:23:10.258 --> 00:23:13.043
around... 12:30 a.m.?

396
00:23:13.087 --> 00:23:14.915
Yeah.

397
00:23:14.958 --> 00:23:17.004
Yeah, he...

398
00:23:17.047 --> 00:23:18.571
he got out of my car.

399
00:23:18.614 --> 00:23:19.833
I had a stomach ache,

400
00:23:19.876 --> 00:23:21.878
so I just went
back to his house.

401
00:23:21.922 --> 00:23:24.403
We got your blood results
back from the hospital.

402
00:23:24.446 --> 00:23:28.189
You had a .093%
at nine this morning.

403
00:23:28.232 --> 00:23:30.539
That's still
over the legal limit.

404
00:23:32.149 --> 00:23:34.674
Guess you guys were tying one on
pretty good last night.

405
00:23:34.761 --> 00:23:36.763
Everybody was drinking.

406
00:23:36.850 --> 00:23:40.375
I mean, I had
a couple drinks at McCarthy's,

407
00:23:40.419 --> 00:23:42.290
a couple more
at the Waterfall.

408
00:23:42.333 --> 00:23:44.423
I... I felt fine.

409
00:23:44.466 --> 00:23:46.250
Fine enough
to get behind the wheel?

410
00:23:46.294 --> 00:23:49.645
Yeah. Well,
I got home in one piece.

411
00:23:49.689 --> 00:23:52.518
I noticed, on the way in,
you got a busted tail light.

412
00:23:52.518 --> 00:23:55.782
Yeah, that, um...
that happened this morning.

413
00:23:57.044 --> 00:23:58.915
I backed into John's car.

414
00:24:01.352 --> 00:24:04.399
He's missing.
I-I was frantic.

415
00:24:04.486 --> 00:24:06.923
Well, since the car's
the last place anyone saw John,

416
00:24:06.967 --> 00:24:08.055
I'm afraid
I'm gonna have to take that in

417
00:24:08.055 --> 00:24:08.969
to be investigated.

418
00:24:10.536 --> 00:24:12.189
Are you serious?

419
00:24:12.233 --> 00:24:13.800
You're gonna take my car?

420
00:24:15.628 --> 00:24:17.978
Well, how am I supposed
to get to work?

421
00:24:18.021 --> 00:24:19.980
Can you work from home?

422
00:24:20.023 --> 00:24:23.549
I mean,
I-I'm a financial analyst--

423
00:24:23.592 --> 00:24:25.289
I can do that work from home,

424
00:24:25.333 --> 00:24:27.030
but I also teach finance
at the university.

425
00:24:27.074 --> 00:24:28.771
Sorry, the car's evidence.

426
00:24:28.815 --> 00:24:31.252
I'm afraid we're also gonna
have to ask for your phone.

427
00:24:31.295 --> 00:24:33.994
What?

428
00:24:49.531 --> 00:24:51.664
I think
I'm gonna need a lawyer.

429
00:24:55.058 --> 00:24:57.931
So, the first thing that
we can expect, most likely,

430
00:24:58.018 --> 00:24:59.802
is a no-contact order.

431
00:24:59.846 --> 00:25:02.022
"No contact"?
What does that even--

432
00:25:03.589 --> 00:25:04.981
With who?

433
00:25:05.068 --> 00:25:07.767
With anyone in John's family.

434
00:25:07.810 --> 00:25:10.030
And I'm afraid that means

435
00:25:10.160 --> 00:25:12.511
that you won't be able
to attend John's funeral.

436
00:25:12.554 --> 00:25:13.990
What?

437
00:25:14.077 --> 00:25:16.558
No contact...
with his family at all.

438
00:25:16.602 --> 00:25:17.472
I'm really sorry.

439
00:25:18.995 --> 00:25:21.737
They all
have their minds made up.

440
00:25:21.781 --> 00:25:24.305
You know, three days ago,
I was like family to them,

441
00:25:24.348 --> 00:25:27.177
and all of a sudden,
no contact?

442
00:25:27.264 --> 00:25:28.962
I mean,
is that even necessary?

443
00:25:29.005 --> 00:25:31.225
No one's speaking to me,
anyway.

444
00:25:31.268 --> 00:25:32.356
They're almost certainly
gonna fill a warrant out

445
00:25:32.400 --> 00:25:33.140
for your arrest.

446
00:25:34.228 --> 00:25:35.838
My arrest?

447
00:25:35.882 --> 00:25:38.624
I didn't do anything.
This is insane!

448
00:25:48.285 --> 00:25:49.635
Look, that night...

449
00:25:53.682 --> 00:25:54.814
...I had been drinking.

450
00:25:57.817 --> 00:25:59.166
It was late...

451
00:26:01.647 --> 00:26:04.432
...and, I mean, I don't know
what could've happened.

452
00:26:08.610 --> 00:26:10.525
Did he try to get to me
while I was leaving

453
00:26:10.656 --> 00:26:13.354
and I just didn't--
I didn't know it?

454
00:26:13.397 --> 00:26:15.443
I mean, I-I always
have the music blasting.

455
00:26:15.486 --> 00:26:17.401
It-- It was snowing,
I had the wipers going.

456
00:26:17.445 --> 00:26:19.099
I had the-the heater blasting.

457
00:26:19.142 --> 00:26:20.448
I mean...

458
00:26:22.581 --> 00:26:23.582
What if... and...

459
00:26:25.279 --> 00:26:26.541
I don't even know.

460
00:26:26.585 --> 00:26:28.456
What if I...

461
00:26:28.499 --> 00:26:30.284
ran over his foot?

462
00:26:30.327 --> 00:26:33.592
Or-Or what if I-I--
I clipped him in the knee

463
00:26:33.635 --> 00:26:35.724
and he just--
he just passed out?

464
00:26:35.811 --> 00:26:39.206
Well, then you would have
some element of culpability.

465
00:26:40.511 --> 00:26:41.600
They took your phone.

466
00:26:41.643 --> 00:26:43.906
They took... your car.

467
00:26:43.993 --> 00:26:45.952
You need to prepare yourself.

468
00:26:47.910 --> 00:26:50.043
How is anybody
supposed to prepare themselves

469
00:26:50.130 --> 00:26:51.653
for something like this?

470
00:26:51.740 --> 00:26:55.004
Well, you can also expect
some fairly invasive discovery--

471
00:26:55.004 --> 00:26:56.440
subpoenas for your texts,

472
00:26:56.484 --> 00:26:58.791
your emails,
your financial records.

473
00:27:00.401 --> 00:27:02.359
I'll talk to the D.A.
and arrange

474
00:27:02.446 --> 00:27:04.187
for you
to voluntarily surrender.

475
00:27:04.231 --> 00:27:06.625
Everybody's so damn sure.

476
00:27:06.668 --> 00:27:08.583
Burn me at the stake, already.

477
00:27:08.627 --> 00:27:09.889
Listen, Karen.

478
00:27:11.630 --> 00:27:14.633
I'm gonna be with you
through the whole thing.

479
00:27:14.633 --> 00:27:18.419
I've been practicing law
for 30-plus years.

480
00:27:18.462 --> 00:27:20.116
They're gonna
take your picture.

481
00:27:20.203 --> 00:27:21.465
They'll take your prints.

482
00:27:21.509 --> 00:27:22.684
You post bail,

483
00:27:22.771 --> 00:27:24.904
you go home.

484
00:28:06.032 --> 00:28:07.207
Just behind me

485
00:28:07.250 --> 00:28:09.688
is the location
of the tragic death

486
00:28:09.731 --> 00:28:11.994
of Boston Police Officer
John O'Keefe,

487
00:28:12.038 --> 00:28:14.562
where investigations
have intensified.

488
00:28:22.875 --> 00:28:23.876
More tail-light
pieces over here.

489
00:28:29.229 --> 00:28:31.100
Family,
friends, and fellow officers

490
00:28:31.231 --> 00:28:32.798
gathered today

491
00:28:32.841 --> 00:28:34.843
at the St. Francis of Assisi
Church in Braintree,

492
00:28:34.887 --> 00:28:37.585
for the funeral of Boston
police officer John O'Keefe.

493
00:28:37.628 --> 00:28:39.369
O'Keefe was pronounced dead
Saturday,

494
00:28:39.413 --> 00:28:41.023
in the early-morning hours,

495
00:28:41.110 --> 00:28:44.374
after being found in the snow
outside a home in Canton.

496
00:28:44.418 --> 00:28:46.115
His brother Paul
remembered John

497
00:28:46.159 --> 00:28:48.422
as someone who showed
what determination could be.

498
00:28:48.509 --> 00:28:50.163
Moving forward,

499
00:28:50.250 --> 00:28:51.425
I will do my best

500
00:28:51.468 --> 00:28:53.035
to continue
my brother's legacy

501
00:28:53.079 --> 00:28:55.037
of caring
and supporting others,

502
00:28:55.081 --> 00:28:57.300
even though I know
I can never come close

503
00:28:57.344 --> 00:28:58.693
to the way he did.

504
00:28:58.780 --> 00:29:01.304
Nor can I come close

505
00:29:01.348 --> 00:29:05.178
to expressing
the admiration I have for John,

506
00:29:05.221 --> 00:29:07.789
who, after
our sister Kristi died,

507
00:29:07.833 --> 00:29:10.270
took her two children
into his home

508
00:29:10.357 --> 00:29:11.837
to raise as his.

509
00:29:13.795 --> 00:29:15.971
But I can repeat

510
00:29:16.015 --> 00:29:19.453
the same words that John used
at Kristi's funeral--

511
00:29:20.846 --> 00:29:22.935
"We'll take it from here."

512
00:29:24.501 --> 00:29:26.112
John O'Keefe
will be laid to rest

513
00:29:26.155 --> 00:29:28.244
at Bluehill Cemetery
in Braintree.

514
00:29:30.029 --> 00:29:32.118
David, hi.

515
00:29:32.161 --> 00:29:34.990
Hey. Listen.
I've got some bad news.

516
00:29:35.077 --> 00:29:36.426
Terrific.

517
00:29:36.470 --> 00:29:38.211
I talked to the D.A.

518
00:29:38.254 --> 00:29:39.429
and they're not going for it.

519
00:29:39.473 --> 00:29:41.475
They won't let you
voluntarily surrender.

520
00:29:41.562 --> 00:29:43.607
What? Why?

521
00:29:43.651 --> 00:29:44.826
Well...

522
00:29:44.870 --> 00:29:46.872
they're not telling me anything,
but...

523
00:29:46.915 --> 00:29:48.569
a Boston cop is dead,

524
00:29:48.612 --> 00:29:50.092
and we knew

525
00:29:50.136 --> 00:29:51.790
there was a heightened
sense of importance to it--

526
00:29:51.833 --> 00:29:53.704
they're playing their cards
very close.

527
00:29:53.792 --> 00:29:56.098
So they're insisting
on arresting me?

528
00:29:57.665 --> 00:29:59.710
David, how am I
supposed to go to jail?

529
00:29:59.710 --> 00:30:01.930
I mean, I've got Crohn's,
I've got MS.

530
00:30:01.974 --> 00:30:04.106
I've got all these meds
I have to take.

531
00:30:04.150 --> 00:30:05.978
Okay, you can
bring them with you.

532
00:30:07.414 --> 00:30:09.198
All right. When?

533
00:30:09.242 --> 00:30:11.548
Well...
that's why I'm calling.

534
00:30:11.635 --> 00:30:13.115
Are you home?

535
00:30:13.159 --> 00:30:14.508
Yeah.

536
00:30:55.549 --> 00:30:58.073
Okay.
Just like we talked about.

537
00:31:07.343 --> 00:31:09.128
David, I have to hang up now.

538
00:31:10.825 --> 00:31:13.175
Karen Read,

539
00:31:13.219 --> 00:31:14.698
you have the right
to remain silent.

540
00:31:14.742 --> 00:31:17.005
Anything you say

541
00:31:17.049 --> 00:31:19.225
can be used against you
in a court of law.

542
00:31:20.966 --> 00:31:22.706
If you cannot afford
an attorney,

543
00:31:22.750 --> 00:31:25.709
one will be provided to you
by the State.

544
00:31:39.027 --> 00:31:40.681
Police have
arrested a Mansfield woman

545
00:31:40.724 --> 00:31:42.248
in connection with

546
00:31:42.335 --> 00:31:44.772
the death of Boston
police officer John O'Keefe,

547
00:31:44.815 --> 00:31:46.992
who was found in a snowbank
on a Canton street

548
00:31:47.079 --> 00:31:48.341
over the weekend.

549
00:31:50.691 --> 00:31:52.649
Investigators allege

550
00:31:52.736 --> 00:31:55.914
that Read struck O'Keefe
with her black Lexus SUV,

551
00:31:56.001 --> 00:31:57.654
and left him to die
in the snow

552
00:31:57.741 --> 00:31:58.917
outside a Canton home

553
00:31:59.004 --> 00:32:02.572
in the frigid
blizzard conditions.

554
00:32:02.616 --> 00:32:04.009
Manslaughter,
motor-vehicle homicide,

555
00:32:04.139 --> 00:32:05.619
and leaving the scene

556
00:32:05.662 --> 00:32:08.317
of a motor-vehicle collision
causing death.

557
00:32:08.361 --> 00:32:09.231
Do you understand
these charges?

558
00:32:09.275 --> 00:32:10.711
Yeah.

559
00:32:10.754 --> 00:32:11.799
This arrest

560
00:32:11.930 --> 00:32:13.453
marks the first
major development

561
00:32:13.496 --> 00:32:16.369
in the investigation
into O'Keefe's death,

562
00:32:16.456 --> 00:32:18.284
which shocked the local
law-enforcement community.

563
00:33:22.696 --> 00:33:23.697
Can I get a vodka soda?

564
00:33:28.832 --> 00:33:30.225
Here you go.

565
00:33:30.269 --> 00:33:31.226
Start snowing yet?

566
00:33:31.270 --> 00:33:33.228
No, not yet.

567
00:33:33.315 --> 00:33:34.882
You know, my dad said
I shouldn't be out

568
00:33:34.925 --> 00:33:37.232
with a blizzard on the way.

569
00:33:37.319 --> 00:33:38.886
I'll take another.

570
00:33:45.588 --> 00:33:46.372
Uh, Chris Albert.

571
00:33:49.592 --> 00:33:51.203
A bunch of them
down by the Waterfall.

572
00:33:51.246 --> 00:33:52.421
Can we just hang here?

573
00:33:52.465 --> 00:33:54.032
-Do you want to go?
-No.

574
00:33:56.295 --> 00:33:57.209
Come on, look at me.

575
00:33:57.252 --> 00:33:58.471
Look at my eyes.

576
00:33:58.514 --> 00:33:59.863
Four shots.

577
00:33:59.907 --> 00:34:01.430
-Here you go.
-All right!

578
00:34:01.474 --> 00:34:02.736
You guys in?

579
00:34:02.736 --> 00:34:04.390
Yours. Here we go.

580
00:34:05.869 --> 00:34:06.653
Up yours.

581
00:34:10.352 --> 00:34:11.875
Let's go and say hi.

582
00:34:11.919 --> 00:34:14.356
Look, it'll be easier to go by,
have a drink,

583
00:34:14.400 --> 00:34:15.923
than come up with some excuse.

584
00:34:15.966 --> 00:34:17.142
-Okay, fine. Let's go.
-Yeah, we're going?

585
00:34:17.229 --> 00:34:18.230
Yeah, let's go.

586
00:34:18.273 --> 00:34:20.101
Hey, Saint John! Johnny!

587
00:34:20.145 --> 00:34:21.842
-Hey!
-Hey!

588
00:34:21.929 --> 00:34:23.583
Who invited these losers?

589
00:34:23.626 --> 00:34:25.150
Hey, blame your brother.

590
00:34:25.193 --> 00:34:26.890
Hey, what are
you pricks drinking?

591
00:34:26.934 --> 00:34:28.805
Whatever you pricks
are buying.

592
00:34:28.892 --> 00:34:29.937
You kiss that mouth?

593
00:34:30.024 --> 00:34:31.330
Hey!

594
00:34:31.373 --> 00:34:32.070
Best way I know to shut her up.

595
00:34:32.113 --> 00:34:33.114
Come on!

596
00:34:35.943 --> 00:34:37.510
We're good, right?

597
00:34:37.597 --> 00:34:38.598
You in?

598
00:34:38.641 --> 00:34:40.600
-No.
-You in?

599
00:34:43.037 --> 00:34:44.908
Let's go back to my place.

600
00:34:44.952 --> 00:34:46.127
Don't forget
to let those guys know.

601
00:34:46.171 --> 00:34:47.433
Oh, yeah. I'll let 'em know.

602
00:34:47.476 --> 00:34:49.304
Hey, we're all going
back to Brian's place.

603
00:34:49.348 --> 00:34:50.131
You coming?

604
00:34:50.218 --> 00:34:52.090
Uh... yeah.

605
00:34:52.133 --> 00:34:53.439
Yeah!

606
00:34:54.918 --> 00:34:55.876
Really?

607
00:34:55.963 --> 00:34:57.138
What?

608
00:34:57.182 --> 00:34:58.400
Well, it's after midnight.

609
00:34:58.444 --> 00:34:59.706
Can't we just go
back to your house?

610
00:34:59.749 --> 00:35:00.750
You and me?

611
00:35:00.794 --> 00:35:02.187
One drink.

612
00:35:02.230 --> 00:35:03.362
Come on, we'll be a minute.

613
00:35:03.405 --> 00:35:04.667
We're having a good time.

614
00:35:04.798 --> 00:35:06.104
All right.

615
00:35:06.147 --> 00:35:06.974
Are you coming?

616
00:35:15.417 --> 00:35:17.724
Hey.

617
00:35:17.767 --> 00:35:19.465
Oh, thank God.
You have to get me

618
00:35:19.508 --> 00:35:21.162
out of this cell.
-Well, they're gonna be here

619
00:35:21.206 --> 00:35:23.033
in a minute, to bring you
over to your arraignment.

620
00:35:23.121 --> 00:35:25.035
Are-Are they gonna let me
get cleaned up a bit?

621
00:35:25.123 --> 00:35:26.950
I mean, look at me.

622
00:35:26.994 --> 00:35:28.909
No one's gonna care about that.

623
00:35:28.996 --> 00:35:31.390
Listen, I've been going through
your arrest record,

624
00:35:31.477 --> 00:35:33.479
and there are a few things
that we're gonna need

625
00:35:33.522 --> 00:35:34.610
to address,
going forward.

626
00:35:34.610 --> 00:35:35.655
What are they saying?

627
00:35:35.742 --> 00:35:37.178
Well, first,

628
00:35:37.222 --> 00:35:41.269
your blood alcohol level
that morning was .09--

629
00:35:41.313 --> 00:35:43.793
Yeah, I already know that.
What else?

630
00:35:43.837 --> 00:35:45.447
Okay. Evidence--

631
00:35:45.491 --> 00:35:46.796
there were pieces
of a broken tail-light,

632
00:35:46.840 --> 00:35:48.537
close to John's body,

633
00:35:48.581 --> 00:35:50.800
consistent with
the broken tail-light

634
00:35:50.844 --> 00:35:51.975
of your Lexus SUV.

635
00:35:52.019 --> 00:35:54.152
There were pieces
of broken glass

636
00:35:54.195 --> 00:35:56.371
embedded in your bumper
that, they say,

637
00:35:56.415 --> 00:35:59.853
came from a glass that John took
from the Waterfall.

638
00:35:59.940 --> 00:36:01.898
There were scratches, dents,
and chipped paint

639
00:36:01.985 --> 00:36:05.424
all around that same back area
of your car.

640
00:36:05.467 --> 00:36:07.382
-Shit.
-Basically, they are saying

641
00:36:07.426 --> 00:36:09.123
that you drove
to the Alberts' house,

642
00:36:09.167 --> 00:36:10.690
John got out,
you backed up,

643
00:36:10.733 --> 00:36:12.170
slamming into him.

644
00:36:12.300 --> 00:36:13.780
After which,
you drove to his place,

645
00:36:13.823 --> 00:36:15.434
where you fell asleep,

646
00:36:15.477 --> 00:36:18.741
leaving him laying there
overnight

647
00:36:18.828 --> 00:36:20.874
to freeze to death.

648
00:36:22.441 --> 00:36:25.226
He got out of the car.

649
00:36:25.270 --> 00:36:28.447
I watched him
head over to the house.

650
00:36:28.490 --> 00:36:30.623
That was the last time
I ever saw him.

651
00:36:30.710 --> 00:36:33.800
And then, they have
people on the scene that morning

652
00:36:33.843 --> 00:36:36.150
that swear
that they heard you say,

653
00:36:36.194 --> 00:36:37.282
"I hit him.

654
00:36:37.325 --> 00:36:38.848
I hit him. I hit him."

655
00:36:38.892 --> 00:36:40.589
David...

656
00:36:40.633 --> 00:36:42.635
I never said those words.

657
00:36:42.678 --> 00:36:44.027
Ever.

658
00:36:44.114 --> 00:36:46.073
There are people
on the scene that morning

659
00:36:46.116 --> 00:36:46.987
that say you did.

660
00:37:00.261 --> 00:37:04.396
What the hell?
Am I-- Am I news now?

661
00:37:13.143 --> 00:37:15.668
How does the defendant plead?

662
00:37:15.755 --> 00:37:17.757
Not guilty, your Honor.

663
00:37:20.586 --> 00:37:23.328
Court sets bail
in the amount of $50,000,

664
00:37:23.371 --> 00:37:24.938
and reiterates, Ms. Read--

665
00:37:24.981 --> 00:37:26.200
...that you are ordered

666
00:37:26.244 --> 00:37:28.376
to stay away
from the victim's residence,

667
00:37:28.420 --> 00:37:30.204
and have no contact
with the victim's family.

668
00:37:39.692 --> 00:37:40.606
Karen Read,

669
00:37:40.606 --> 00:37:42.999
the girlfriend of John O'Keefe,

670
00:37:43.043 --> 00:37:44.914
was released on bail today

671
00:37:44.958 --> 00:37:47.395
shortly after
she appeared in court

672
00:37:47.439 --> 00:37:50.137
to face charges
related to his death.

673
00:37:50.180 --> 00:37:52.661
She's pleaded "not guilty"
to manslaughter,

674
00:37:52.705 --> 00:37:54.402
motor-vehicular homicide,

675
00:37:54.489 --> 00:37:57.579
and leaving the scene
of a collision causing death.

676
00:37:57.623 --> 00:38:00.365
The victim,
Officer John O'Keefe, 46,

677
00:38:00.408 --> 00:38:02.192
was a 16-year veteran

678
00:38:02.236 --> 00:38:04.107
of the Boston
Police Department.

679
00:38:04.151 --> 00:38:06.893
Karen Read has denied
all the allegations

680
00:38:06.936 --> 00:38:09.069
and maintains her innocence.

681
00:38:11.898 --> 00:38:14.161
There goes
my health insurance.

682
00:38:14.204 --> 00:38:16.163
You know, I have--
I have surgery follow-ups.

683
00:38:16.206 --> 00:38:18.034
How am I supposed
to pay for my meds,

684
00:38:18.121 --> 00:38:19.209
if I don't have a job?

685
00:38:19.253 --> 00:38:20.950
We'll figure it out.

686
00:38:21.037 --> 00:38:22.778
You know, you always say that.

687
00:38:22.822 --> 00:38:24.432
But how?

688
00:38:24.476 --> 00:38:26.652
How are we gonna
"figure it out"?

689
00:38:26.695 --> 00:38:30.482
Look, you're not gonna
be alone through this.

690
00:38:30.525 --> 00:38:33.006
I'm not at work anymore.

691
00:38:33.049 --> 00:38:35.356
I can be there for you
through the whole thing.

692
00:38:35.400 --> 00:38:37.097
Yeah, but you love your job.

693
00:38:37.184 --> 00:38:38.664
Not more than I love you.

694
00:38:38.751 --> 00:38:40.187
Ugh.

695
00:38:41.971 --> 00:38:44.278
I'm gonna be
put in the poorhouse

696
00:38:44.322 --> 00:38:46.324
for something
I didn't do, Dad.

697
00:38:46.367 --> 00:38:50.371
I mean, my God--
I had to cash out my 401K.

698
00:38:50.415 --> 00:38:52.330
Probably gonna
have to sell this house.

699
00:38:52.373 --> 00:38:54.157
Honey...

700
00:38:54.244 --> 00:38:57.073
you've got your mom,
you've got me.

701
00:38:57.160 --> 00:38:59.032
We're totally behind you,
and we're gonna help,

702
00:38:59.075 --> 00:39:00.207
whatever it takes.

703
00:39:01.556 --> 00:39:04.559
But how?

704
00:39:04.603 --> 00:39:07.432
By doing
whatever we need to do.

705
00:39:08.781 --> 00:39:10.826
This fight--
it's not just you.

706
00:39:10.870 --> 00:39:13.046
It's us, too.

707
00:39:13.089 --> 00:39:16.049
And we're not gonna stop
till we make this right.

708
00:39:20.227 --> 00:39:22.055
It just feels like
this whole town

709
00:39:22.098 --> 00:39:24.884
is turning on me.

710
00:39:24.927 --> 00:39:27.626
They're telling the cops
I said I hit him.

711
00:39:27.669 --> 00:39:29.062
Why?

712
00:39:30.324 --> 00:39:31.978
Why would I say that?

713
00:39:32.065 --> 00:39:34.720
I thought these people
were supposed to be my friends.

714
00:39:59.135 --> 00:40:00.267
What in the--?

715
00:40:16.718 --> 00:40:18.241
What? What now?

716
00:40:18.328 --> 00:40:19.591
I have an arrest warrant.

717
00:40:19.678 --> 00:40:22.855
Again? Who have I
supposed to have killed now?

718
00:40:22.898 --> 00:40:24.378
Same person.

719
00:40:24.422 --> 00:40:25.858
Only the charges have been upped
from manslaughter

720
00:40:25.901 --> 00:40:27.250
to second-degree murder.

721
00:40:27.294 --> 00:40:29.078
Can I at least get
some normal shoes on,

722
00:40:29.122 --> 00:40:31.341
so that I don't have to go on TV
looking like this?

723
00:40:31.385 --> 00:40:33.387
I don't even have underwear on!

724
00:40:33.431 --> 00:40:35.258
Can I at least
go get some pants?

725
00:40:35.302 --> 00:40:37.304
Your parents can come back
and retrieve everything.

726
00:40:39.393 --> 00:40:42.527
I just... I don't want to be
on channel 4 in my pajamas.

727
00:40:42.614 --> 00:40:43.919
I wouldn't be worried
about the news right now.

728
00:40:43.963 --> 00:40:46.356
See how she is?

729
00:40:46.400 --> 00:40:48.141
She's more concerned
with how she looks on TV.

730
00:40:48.184 --> 00:40:49.751
Yeah, okay.

731
00:40:49.795 --> 00:40:52.580
Manslaughter,
second-degree murder...

732
00:40:52.667 --> 00:40:54.452
what's-- what's the difference?

733
00:40:54.495 --> 00:40:56.410
Life in prison.

734
00:41:07.987 --> 00:41:08.335
I mean, that's the problem
with these people--

735
00:41:08.988 --> 00:41:10.468
everything is,
"We're all gonna die

736
00:41:10.511 --> 00:41:11.991
if we don't get rid
of plastic bags

737
00:41:12.034 --> 00:41:13.079
out of supermarkets,"

738
00:41:13.166 --> 00:41:15.124
and "no more straws."

739
00:41:15.168 --> 00:41:17.083
Everything is,
"We're all gonna die."

740
00:41:17.170 --> 00:41:19.477
Anyway, that's my take.

741
00:41:19.564 --> 00:41:21.261
For those of you just joining
or are here for the first time,

742
00:41:21.304 --> 00:41:23.306
I'm your fearless host,
Turtleboy.

743
00:41:23.350 --> 00:41:24.873
Let's take a call.

744
00:41:24.917 --> 00:41:26.962
Hey, "Steve From Southie,"
what's on your mind?

745
00:41:27.006 --> 00:41:28.311
Hey, man.

746
00:41:28.355 --> 00:41:30.052
You been following
this Karen Read case?

747
00:41:30.139 --> 00:41:32.359
Sounds like something
right up your alley.

748
00:41:32.402 --> 00:41:34.187
Yeah, a woman who hit
her cop boyfriend with her car?

749
00:41:34.274 --> 00:41:35.057
Yeah. What's your take on that?

750
00:41:35.101 --> 00:41:36.798
Well, it sucks, huh?

751
00:41:36.842 --> 00:41:38.234
You know, I mean,
you got this woman

752
00:41:38.278 --> 00:41:39.932
who's got it all together,
and, um...

753
00:41:39.975 --> 00:41:41.760
she just got drunk one night,

754
00:41:41.803 --> 00:41:42.935
and appears to have
not even known

755
00:41:42.978 --> 00:41:44.502
that she backed this guy over.

756
00:41:44.545 --> 00:41:45.851
I'm sure
she didn't mean to kill him,

757
00:41:45.894 --> 00:41:47.374
and I'm sure
it's eating her up inside.

758
00:41:47.417 --> 00:41:48.680
Well, seems like a story
you should cover.

759
00:41:48.723 --> 00:41:50.159
I mean, uh...

760
00:41:50.203 --> 00:41:51.726
it's sad, yeah,

761
00:41:51.813 --> 00:41:53.598
but I don't know
if there's a story there.

762
00:41:53.641 --> 00:41:55.382
You know,
I'm a "Back-the-Blue" guy,

763
00:41:55.425 --> 00:41:57.515
so, uh, I don't really have
a strong opinion on it.

764
00:41:57.558 --> 00:41:58.864
It's a tragedy.

765
00:41:58.994 --> 00:42:00.256
Yeah, it's a real tragedy
for her.

766
00:42:00.300 --> 00:42:01.649
She's out on bail now,

767
00:42:01.693 --> 00:42:03.999
but they're charging her
with murder.

768
00:42:04.043 --> 00:42:06.175
Murder?

769
00:42:06.219 --> 00:42:07.916
Hold up a sec.

770
00:42:38.643 --> 00:42:40.645
Look at this.

771
00:42:40.688 --> 00:42:42.516
Proctor knows everybody.

772
00:42:42.560 --> 00:42:45.084
He's the lead investigator
on this case,

773
00:42:45.127 --> 00:42:46.868
and I'm there scrolling
through all these pictures,

774
00:42:46.955 --> 00:42:48.217
and it's like
he pretty much knows

775
00:42:48.261 --> 00:42:49.958
everybody who was in that house
that night.

776
00:42:50.002 --> 00:42:51.438
Everyone?

777
00:42:51.569 --> 00:42:53.396
Well, not everyone,

778
00:42:53.440 --> 00:42:56.182
but isn't it
kind of a conflict of interest?

779
00:42:58.619 --> 00:43:00.099
John's a cop.

780
00:43:01.579 --> 00:43:03.145
They're not gonna let this go.

781
00:43:03.232 --> 00:43:05.974
And now it's my ass
that's on the line.

782
00:43:08.324 --> 00:43:10.109
We're gonna need a bigger team.

783
00:43:39.094 --> 00:43:42.228
Are they kidding?

784
00:43:42.271 --> 00:43:43.838
The-These injuries
are from a car hitting him?

785
00:43:43.882 --> 00:43:45.187
That's their story.

786
00:43:45.318 --> 00:43:46.798
Well, I'm not buying it.

787
00:43:46.798 --> 00:43:48.495
Maybe someone
just needed a scapegoat.

788
00:43:48.582 --> 00:43:49.452
Yeah, well,
that's why I'm here.

789
00:43:50.584 --> 00:43:52.717
I mean, come on.

790
00:43:52.760 --> 00:43:54.588
You mean to tell me they're not
seeing what we're seeing?

791
00:43:54.588 --> 00:43:56.546
Exactly our question.

792
00:43:56.634 --> 00:43:57.591
And did anybody else
have their vehicle

793
00:43:57.635 --> 00:43:59.724
and cell phone taken from them?

794
00:43:59.811 --> 00:44:01.464
I mean, it's like
I was the only suspect.

795
00:44:01.464 --> 00:44:02.640
Well, you're the odd one out.

796
00:44:04.293 --> 00:44:05.730
They're circling their wagons--

797
00:44:05.773 --> 00:44:07.514
everybody and his mother.

798
00:44:07.557 --> 00:44:09.168
Putting only you
on the chopping block.

799
00:44:09.211 --> 00:44:10.996
This is intentional--

800
00:44:11.039 --> 00:44:13.825
this slow drip of discovery
from the prosecution.

801
00:44:15.478 --> 00:44:16.305
Well, they're certainly
taking their time.

802
00:44:16.349 --> 00:44:17.655
It's been months.

803
00:44:17.698 --> 00:44:19.700
They've got a game plan.

804
00:44:19.744 --> 00:44:21.136
Well, they're on
a fishing expedition.

805
00:44:21.223 --> 00:44:22.311
Trying to fit the evidence

806
00:44:22.355 --> 00:44:23.922
to the narrative
they already decided on.

807
00:44:23.965 --> 00:44:25.445
You have a fundamental right

808
00:44:25.488 --> 00:44:26.968
to see the evidence
against you,

809
00:44:27.012 --> 00:44:28.448
and they're taking
their sweet time about it.

810
00:44:28.491 --> 00:44:30.929
They didn't waste any time
taking my car

811
00:44:30.972 --> 00:44:33.366
or my phone, did they?

812
00:44:33.409 --> 00:44:35.455
Let's just drill down on this
for just 10 seconds.

813
00:44:35.498 --> 00:44:36.891
In terms of
the tail-light material,

814
00:44:36.935 --> 00:44:39.024
uh, the-the glass,
the plastic, John's shirt,

815
00:44:39.067 --> 00:44:41.156
the jeans, the belt,
the shoes, the underwear,

816
00:44:41.200 --> 00:44:42.680
the hat-- whatever--

817
00:44:42.723 --> 00:44:44.682
Well, none of it was booked
into evidence until...

818
00:44:44.725 --> 00:44:47.597
March 14th, 2022.

819
00:44:47.685 --> 00:44:49.295
So they just sat on it
for a month and a half?

820
00:44:49.338 --> 00:44:50.209
What the hell?
Is that standard?

821
00:44:50.296 --> 00:44:51.906
No, no, no.

822
00:44:51.950 --> 00:44:53.212
No. We-we don't know
whose possession they were in.

823
00:44:53.212 --> 00:44:54.779
I mean,
what were the circumstances?

824
00:44:54.822 --> 00:44:56.302
W-Were they properly handled?

825
00:44:56.345 --> 00:44:58.086
We have no guarantee
they weren't compromised.

826
00:44:58.086 --> 00:45:00.262
Holy shit, Turtle Riders!

827
00:45:00.306 --> 00:45:02.308
This is story-of-the-century
stuff!

828
00:45:02.351 --> 00:45:05.572
I mean, my jaw is...
currently on the floor.

829
00:45:05.615 --> 00:45:07.313
Remember the headlines
that a Boston police officer

830
00:45:07.356 --> 00:45:08.749
was backed over
by his girlfriend

831
00:45:08.793 --> 00:45:10.272
in a snowstorm
after a fight

832
00:45:10.359 --> 00:45:11.883
on a night
they were both drinking?

833
00:45:11.926 --> 00:45:13.580
That was the narrative
that was put out there,

834
00:45:13.623 --> 00:45:15.495
but I have been getting more
and more information on this,

835
00:45:15.538 --> 00:45:16.583
and it's outrageous!

836
00:45:16.583 --> 00:45:18.150
And what we know
for damn sure

837
00:45:18.193 --> 00:45:20.326
is she did not run him over.

838
00:45:20.413 --> 00:45:22.632
No, Karen Read
is a completely innocent woman.

839
00:45:22.720 --> 00:45:25.635
He is something else.

840
00:45:25.679 --> 00:45:27.246
We couldn't get better PR
if we were paying him.

841
00:45:27.333 --> 00:45:28.508
Yeah.

842
00:45:28.551 --> 00:45:30.336
That's because
he's 100% sincere--

843
00:45:30.379 --> 00:45:32.294
a force to be reckoned with.

844
00:45:32.338 --> 00:45:33.513
We're to believe

845
00:45:33.556 --> 00:45:35.733
that Karen was
at least 62 feet away

846
00:45:35.776 --> 00:45:38.083
before she decided
to gun it in reverse,

847
00:45:38.126 --> 00:45:40.085
and John just...
stood there.

848
00:45:40.085 --> 00:45:42.652
Right?
Just waited to get run over?

849
00:45:42.740 --> 00:45:43.828
Is he dead?

850
00:45:43.915 --> 00:45:45.133
Is he dead?

851
00:45:45.177 --> 00:45:46.874
Kerry! Jen, is he dead?

852
00:45:46.874 --> 00:45:49.181
He's dead. Oh, my God.

853
00:45:49.268 --> 00:45:50.878
Look.

854
00:45:50.965 --> 00:45:52.793
I didn't hear you say it at all.

855
00:45:52.837 --> 00:45:55.404
If I was running around saying,
"I hit him, I hit him,"

856
00:45:55.491 --> 00:45:56.666
you'd think
it would be picked up

857
00:45:56.754 --> 00:45:58.059
by the dash-cam mics.

858
00:45:58.103 --> 00:46:00.148
You'd also be
arrested on the spot.

859
00:46:00.192 --> 00:46:02.194
I mean, we can clearly
hear you say,

860
00:46:02.281 --> 00:46:03.761
"He's dead. He's dead."

861
00:46:03.804 --> 00:46:05.501
But not, "I hit him."

862
00:46:05.588 --> 00:46:07.982
Yeah, you don't hear it,
'cause I never said it.

863
00:46:08.026 --> 00:46:10.289
It's all an elaborate plot
to frame Karen Read.

864
00:46:10.376 --> 00:46:11.638
Now, when I believe
in something,

865
00:46:11.725 --> 00:46:13.858
I don't just say,
"Oh, here's the facts."

866
00:46:13.901 --> 00:46:16.034
No, I go out
and I hold protests,

867
00:46:16.077 --> 00:46:18.906
and I'm looking for
other people to do the same.

868
00:46:22.910 --> 00:46:25.217
Free Karen Read!

869
00:46:25.304 --> 00:46:27.175
Well, we always knew

870
00:46:27.219 --> 00:46:30.004
the key to this case
was seeing people's phones.

871
00:46:30.091 --> 00:46:32.050
You can ask
all the questions you want,

872
00:46:32.093 --> 00:46:33.834
but the hard data--

873
00:46:33.878 --> 00:46:36.576
that is where you find
the really critical stuff

874
00:46:36.619 --> 00:46:38.534
in the 21st century.

875
00:46:38.578 --> 00:46:40.232
Proctor's phone records
are coming in very soon,

876
00:46:40.275 --> 00:46:42.625
or I'm gonna be breathing fire.

877
00:46:42.669 --> 00:46:45.803
Uh... Kerry Roberts
and Jen McCabe's

878
00:46:45.890 --> 00:46:47.369
confirm the timing
of those calls

879
00:46:47.413 --> 00:46:48.718
you made to them
that morning.

880
00:46:48.762 --> 00:46:50.546
We have records
of other investigators.

881
00:46:50.590 --> 00:46:52.157
We have the 9-1-1 records.

882
00:46:54.463 --> 00:46:55.682
Oh, that can't be right.

883
00:46:57.989 --> 00:46:59.468
Did Jen McCabe make
a Google search

884
00:46:59.512 --> 00:47:01.296
at 2:27 that morning?

885
00:47:01.383 --> 00:47:03.646
"How long to die in cold?"

886
00:47:05.083 --> 00:47:07.302
Actually,
she typed in "H-O-S,"

887
00:47:07.346 --> 00:47:09.391
but-but it's...

888
00:47:09.478 --> 00:47:11.698
it's clear what she meant.

889
00:47:20.489 --> 00:47:22.404
Karen? Karen...

890
00:47:22.448 --> 00:47:24.493
Did you kill John O'Keefe?

891
00:47:24.537 --> 00:47:26.278
Karen Read
had nothing to do with it.

892
00:47:26.321 --> 00:47:28.541
This is an innocent woman.

893
00:47:28.584 --> 00:47:31.370
Okay? She is the victim
of a conspiracy.

894
00:47:31.413 --> 00:47:33.285
Now, we won't rest
until we get to the bottom

895
00:47:33.328 --> 00:47:34.982
of exactly
who killed John O'Keefe.

896
00:47:35.069 --> 00:47:37.463
Not only Karen Read
deserves this,

897
00:47:37.550 --> 00:47:39.291
John O'Keefe deserves this,

898
00:47:39.291 --> 00:47:42.120
and has deserved this
from moment one.

899
00:47:42.163 --> 00:47:43.817
It feels like
we're the only ones

900
00:47:43.861 --> 00:47:45.079
who are fighting for the truth

901
00:47:45.079 --> 00:47:47.212
of what happened
to John O'Keefe.

902
00:47:47.299 --> 00:47:48.300
And me,

903
00:47:48.387 --> 00:47:49.605
and my family,

904
00:47:49.649 --> 00:47:50.824
and my attorneys...

905
00:47:50.911 --> 00:47:52.478
we've marshaled every resource

906
00:47:52.565 --> 00:47:53.827
to get to the truth.

907
00:47:56.786 --> 00:47:58.223
We know who spearheaded it.

908
00:47:58.266 --> 00:47:59.615
You all know.

909
00:47:59.659 --> 00:48:02.618
I tried to save his life.

910
00:48:02.662 --> 00:48:04.316
At 6 a.m. in the morning,

911
00:48:04.359 --> 00:48:06.579
I was covered in his blood.

912
00:48:06.622 --> 00:48:09.234
Why were you so angry
with John that night?

913
00:48:12.890 --> 00:48:15.240
Welcome, Turtle Riders!

914
00:48:15.283 --> 00:48:17.416
There are at least
100 to 200 people here with me

915
00:48:17.459 --> 00:48:19.157
on the Rolling Rally,

916
00:48:19.200 --> 00:48:21.507
and we are
peacefully protesting

917
00:48:21.594 --> 00:48:23.639
the murder of John O'Keefe,

918
00:48:23.726 --> 00:48:26.207
and the framing
of an innocent woman.

919
00:48:26.294 --> 00:48:28.993
It is a beautiful day here
for some peaceful protesting,

920
00:48:29.036 --> 00:48:30.168
I'll tell you that much.

921
00:48:30.255 --> 00:48:31.909
There will be no rioting.

922
00:48:31.952 --> 00:48:34.607
No looting.
Nothin' like that.

923
00:48:34.650 --> 00:48:37.915
We are peacefully protesting
the murder

924
00:48:37.958 --> 00:48:38.916
of the adoptive father of two

925
00:48:38.959 --> 00:48:41.005
and a Boston police officer

926
00:48:41.048 --> 00:48:43.268
named John O'Keefe.

927
00:48:43.311 --> 00:48:45.966
We are also protesting

928
00:48:46.010 --> 00:48:47.707
on behalf of Karen Read.

929
00:48:47.750 --> 00:48:49.578
You don't get to frame
innocent people

930
00:48:49.622 --> 00:48:51.667
who did nothing wrong!

931
00:48:55.671 --> 00:48:59.980
Free Karen Read!
Free Karen Read!

932
00:49:00.024 --> 00:49:01.895
The scene outside
the courthouse here is unreal!

933
00:49:01.982 --> 00:49:03.331
Hundreds of people here

934
00:49:03.418 --> 00:49:05.768
you would think
are waiting for a movie star,

935
00:49:05.812 --> 00:49:07.683
but the focus
of their attention

936
00:49:07.814 --> 00:49:10.817
is actually former
college professor Karen Read.

937
00:49:17.519 --> 00:49:19.913
Okay, we're ready
for opening statements.

938
00:49:20.000 --> 00:49:22.742
The defendant, Karen Read,

939
00:49:22.785 --> 00:49:25.440
struck Mr. O'Keefe
with her car,

940
00:49:25.484 --> 00:49:26.528
knocking him onto the ground,

941
00:49:26.528 --> 00:49:29.227
striking his head,

942
00:49:29.314 --> 00:49:30.663
and leaving him lying there

943
00:49:30.706 --> 00:49:32.708
to die
in a blizzard.

944
00:49:32.752 --> 00:49:35.276
Karen Read was framed.

945
00:49:35.320 --> 00:49:38.149
Her car
never struck John O'Keefe.

946
00:49:39.498 --> 00:49:42.718
She did not
cause his death...

947
00:49:42.805 --> 00:49:44.590
and that means

948
00:49:44.633 --> 00:49:46.679
that somebody else did.

949
00:50:06.916 --> 00:50:09.615
Hey, blast from the past.

950
00:50:09.702 --> 00:50:12.400
There he is...
in person.

951
00:50:12.444 --> 00:50:14.663
Damn, look at you.

952
00:50:14.707 --> 00:50:16.665
Shut up.

953
00:50:16.709 --> 00:50:18.102
Oh, uh...

954
00:50:20.060 --> 00:50:22.062
You go all out
for a first date.

955
00:50:22.106 --> 00:50:24.108
How is this our first date?

956
00:50:24.151 --> 00:50:26.458
Okay, well,
first date in 16 years.

957
00:50:26.501 --> 00:50:28.286
Come on in.

958
00:50:28.329 --> 00:50:29.548
Let's get a drink first.

959
00:50:29.635 --> 00:50:31.419
Hey, you're talking
my language.

960
00:50:32.899 --> 00:50:34.814
I mean, I don't know...

961
00:50:34.901 --> 00:50:37.034
either most guys are jerks
or I'm just a bad picker.

962
00:50:38.296 --> 00:50:41.647
But, no, no... ex-husband.
No kids.

963
00:50:41.690 --> 00:50:43.997
What is the matter
with guys these days?

964
00:50:44.041 --> 00:50:45.607
They don't see
that you're a catch?

965
00:50:45.651 --> 00:50:47.435
Well, you didn't.

966
00:50:47.479 --> 00:50:50.351
Uh... you broke up with me.

967
00:50:50.395 --> 00:50:51.570
Oh, well...

968
00:50:51.613 --> 00:50:53.311
Well, I'm smarter now.

969
00:50:55.791 --> 00:50:59.012
So, you're-- you're a dad?

970
00:50:59.056 --> 00:51:00.970
Yeah.

971
00:51:01.014 --> 00:51:03.016
Uh, I guess. Kinda.

972
00:51:03.060 --> 00:51:04.148
"Kinda"?

973
00:51:04.235 --> 00:51:06.367
I mean, on your page...

974
00:51:06.411 --> 00:51:09.501
A-Actually, they're my, uh,
my niece and nephew,

975
00:51:09.544 --> 00:51:11.894
but they're mine now.

976
00:51:11.938 --> 00:51:13.983
They were my-my sister's--
uh, Kristi's...

977
00:51:13.983 --> 00:51:16.247
but, uh...

978
00:51:16.290 --> 00:51:17.857
uh, she died.

979
00:51:17.900 --> 00:51:20.338
Oh, my gosh.
I'm-- I'm so sorry.

980
00:51:20.381 --> 00:51:21.948
It was brain cancer.

981
00:51:22.035 --> 00:51:23.645
And then--

982
00:51:23.689 --> 00:51:25.517
I mean, just when you think
God's had this big laugh,

983
00:51:25.560 --> 00:51:26.735
her husband, Stephen,

984
00:51:26.822 --> 00:51:27.693
has a heart attack
two months later.

985
00:51:27.736 --> 00:51:29.434
Jesus, John.

986
00:51:29.477 --> 00:51:32.741
Yeah. Yeah, and the kids,
you know, are orphans,

987
00:51:32.828 --> 00:51:34.569
and that's...

988
00:51:34.569 --> 00:51:36.702
...you know, that's...

989
00:51:36.745 --> 00:51:39.966
that's when family
needs to step in.

990
00:51:40.009 --> 00:51:41.402
They're good kids.

991
00:51:42.577 --> 00:51:44.101
They're good?

992
00:51:45.493 --> 00:51:47.321
Well, then, I guess
that makes you a saint.

993
00:51:47.365 --> 00:51:48.801
I mean,
they're my niece and nephew.

994
00:51:48.844 --> 00:51:49.889
Yeah, but still...

995
00:51:49.932 --> 00:51:52.457
a single guy
taking on two kids?

996
00:51:55.373 --> 00:51:57.375
Are you sure
I broke up with you?

997
00:51:57.462 --> 00:51:59.246
Doesn't sound right.

998
00:51:59.290 --> 00:52:02.119
Well, you were young...
and stupid.

999
00:52:03.642 --> 00:52:05.426
I'll give you that.

1000
00:52:05.470 --> 00:52:06.732
Well...

1001
00:52:06.775 --> 00:52:08.821
here is to new beginnings.

1002
00:52:08.864 --> 00:52:10.518
To new beginnings.

1003
00:52:14.870 --> 00:52:18.004
Uh, "Karen", is it?

1004
00:52:18.091 --> 00:52:20.224
Don't you remember
last night?

1005
00:52:20.267 --> 00:52:22.226
And twice this morning?

1006
00:52:24.619 --> 00:52:27.013
Well, I gave you a key
a month ago.

1007
00:52:27.056 --> 00:52:28.623
You never use it.

1008
00:52:28.667 --> 00:52:31.278
I like it when
my man opens the door for me.

1009
00:52:31.322 --> 00:52:32.714
-Ah.
-Mm.

1010
00:52:32.801 --> 00:52:34.194
Where are the kids?

1011
00:52:34.238 --> 00:52:35.891
Ah, you just missed them.
They went to bed.

1012
00:52:35.978 --> 00:52:37.763
Oh, sounds good.

1013
00:52:37.850 --> 00:52:40.113
Come on, close the door.

1014
00:52:49.688 --> 00:52:51.385
What's going on?

1015
00:52:51.429 --> 00:52:52.517
Gotta go to work.

1016
00:52:54.475 --> 00:52:55.563
Blow it off.

1017
00:52:55.607 --> 00:52:56.695
Can't blow it off.

1018
00:52:56.738 --> 00:52:57.826
Oh, come on.

1019
00:52:59.306 --> 00:53:01.482
You can be a little late. Hmm?

1020
00:53:04.181 --> 00:53:04.877
Come on.

1021
00:53:09.011 --> 00:53:10.187
Is she moving in?

1022
00:53:10.230 --> 00:53:12.014
Yeah. You'd think
she already did.

1023
00:53:12.058 --> 00:53:13.581
She's, uh, pretty much
already always here.

1024
00:53:13.625 --> 00:53:15.279
Is that a good thing or--?

1025
00:53:15.366 --> 00:53:17.324
Yeah. Yeah, she's great.

1026
00:53:17.411 --> 00:53:18.978
And she's great with the kids.

1027
00:53:19.065 --> 00:53:20.458
She is good with the kids.

1028
00:53:20.588 --> 00:53:22.416
It's nice to have some help,
you know what I mean?

1029
00:53:22.460 --> 00:53:24.201
What does, uh, Erin think?

1030
00:53:24.244 --> 00:53:26.028
She likes her.

1031
00:53:26.072 --> 00:53:27.856
I like her, too.

1032
00:53:29.293 --> 00:53:30.729
What're you driving at?
You shopping for rings?

1033
00:53:30.816 --> 00:53:33.079
No, I'm just...

1034
00:53:33.166 --> 00:53:34.472
I'm asking
for an outside opinion.

1035
00:53:34.515 --> 00:53:36.256
So you got my opinion.

1036
00:53:36.300 --> 00:53:38.040
She's a thumbs-up.

1037
00:53:39.781 --> 00:53:42.306
Are we seriously having
an argument over donuts?

1038
00:53:42.393 --> 00:53:44.221
It's not about donuts.

1039
00:53:44.264 --> 00:53:45.700
It's about me
telling the kids no,

1040
00:53:45.787 --> 00:53:47.441
and you buying them
donuts anyway.

1041
00:53:47.441 --> 00:53:49.530
We were running
all around town,

1042
00:53:49.574 --> 00:53:51.315
doing errands.

1043
00:53:51.358 --> 00:53:53.012
I thought
I was doing something nice,

1044
00:53:53.055 --> 00:53:54.274
so shoot me.

1045
00:53:54.274 --> 00:53:56.407
Just don't contradict me
to them. Huh?

1046
00:53:56.450 --> 00:53:57.930
You're not their mother.

1047
00:54:00.976 --> 00:54:02.500
I don't need
a fun "Aunt Karen"

1048
00:54:02.630 --> 00:54:04.502
overriding everything
I tell them.

1049
00:54:04.545 --> 00:54:06.982
Seems to me like
you don't want them

1050
00:54:07.026 --> 00:54:08.941
seeing me
as a mother figure.

1051
00:54:08.984 --> 00:54:10.116
Did I say that?
When did I say that?

1052
00:54:15.861 --> 00:54:18.124
What's really going on
here, John?

1053
00:54:18.211 --> 00:54:19.865
You keep picking
all these fights with me lately,

1054
00:54:19.908 --> 00:54:21.562
and they're always
all about something

1055
00:54:21.606 --> 00:54:23.085
that I'm doing wrong
around here--

1056
00:54:23.129 --> 00:54:24.783
I'm spoiling the kids,

1057
00:54:24.826 --> 00:54:26.480
I'm reorganizing the pantry,
I'm moving the towels--

1058
00:54:26.524 --> 00:54:27.829
Ask first!

1059
00:54:27.873 --> 00:54:29.440
Oh, I'm sorry, John.

1060
00:54:29.483 --> 00:54:31.180
Crime of the century.

1061
00:54:31.224 --> 00:54:32.834
I just want to be
part of the decision-making

1062
00:54:32.921 --> 00:54:34.401
in my own house!

1063
00:54:34.445 --> 00:54:35.533
That's all.

1064
00:54:39.188 --> 00:54:41.452
Look, I...

1065
00:54:42.844 --> 00:54:44.324
I want you around.

1066
00:54:44.368 --> 00:54:45.934
I like it.

1067
00:54:45.978 --> 00:54:49.460
I... I'm not trying
to push you away,

1068
00:54:49.503 --> 00:54:51.853
I'm just-- I am just a guy
who's set in his ways.

1069
00:54:51.897 --> 00:54:53.202
Hmm.

1070
00:54:53.246 --> 00:54:55.988
And I am trying my best.

1071
00:54:57.076 --> 00:55:00.384
Now...

1072
00:55:00.427 --> 00:55:02.777
do you have
any more of those donuts?

1073
00:55:04.344 --> 00:55:06.172
Hey, I am a cop, after all.

1074
00:55:06.215 --> 00:55:07.608
Mm. A charming one, luckily.

1075
00:55:07.652 --> 00:55:09.306
Yeah?

1076
00:55:12.309 --> 00:55:14.049
You okay, babe?

1077
00:55:14.136 --> 00:55:15.790
Yeah, whatever.

1078
00:55:15.834 --> 00:55:17.314
Yeah?

1079
00:55:18.750 --> 00:55:19.794
Well, anyway...

1080
00:55:19.838 --> 00:55:22.928
do...

1081
00:55:22.971 --> 00:55:25.887
do you want to go to Aruba?

1082
00:55:25.931 --> 00:55:27.715
What are you talking about?

1083
00:55:27.759 --> 00:55:29.151
Laura invited us to Aruba.

1084
00:55:29.195 --> 00:55:30.979
Uh, they go every New Year's.

1085
00:55:31.023 --> 00:55:32.416
There's a--
There's a group of them.

1086
00:55:35.506 --> 00:55:37.551
Who's gonna say no to Aruba?

1087
00:55:37.638 --> 00:55:38.596
Ahh!

1088
00:55:38.683 --> 00:55:39.597
Shh.

1089
00:55:39.597 --> 00:55:40.859
Huh? Shh.

1090
00:55:43.688 --> 00:55:44.819
John!

1091
00:55:44.863 --> 00:55:46.125
-Hey!
-What the hell was that?

1092
00:55:46.168 --> 00:55:47.300
What?

1093
00:55:47.344 --> 00:55:48.345
You're making out
with some girl?

1094
00:55:48.388 --> 00:55:49.607
Oh, th-that's Marietta.

1095
00:55:49.650 --> 00:55:50.825
That's, uh,
Laura's little sister.

1096
00:55:50.869 --> 00:55:52.610
I was saying thanks.

1097
00:55:52.697 --> 00:55:53.654
Oh, with your tongue?

1098
00:55:53.698 --> 00:55:54.742
Jesus!

1099
00:55:54.786 --> 00:55:57.049
Um, hi. Nice to meet you.

1100
00:55:57.092 --> 00:55:58.572
Go screw yourself.

1101
00:55:58.659 --> 00:55:59.834
Both of you.

1102
00:55:59.878 --> 00:56:01.096
Karen!

1103
00:56:01.183 --> 00:56:02.315
Karen, that is--

1104
00:56:02.359 --> 00:56:03.229
No. Don't talk to me.

1105
00:56:10.149 --> 00:56:12.151
Look,
I'm embarrassed, too, all right?

1106
00:56:12.194 --> 00:56:13.979
I-I was totally outta line.

1107
00:56:15.284 --> 00:56:17.591
I apologized to everyone.

1108
00:56:17.635 --> 00:56:20.333
I-I even told Marietta
I'd pay for her room.

1109
00:56:20.420 --> 00:56:21.421
Okay. That's great, Karen.

1110
00:56:21.465 --> 00:56:23.292
I'm sure she appreciated it.

1111
00:56:23.380 --> 00:56:25.294
No. She didn't.

1112
00:56:25.338 --> 00:56:26.731
She wasn't gonna let me do that,

1113
00:56:26.774 --> 00:56:28.428
'cause that would mean
accepting my apology,

1114
00:56:28.472 --> 00:56:30.169
and I could tell
she'd rather die than do that.

1115
00:56:30.212 --> 00:56:32.040
Okay! We're home!

1116
00:56:32.084 --> 00:56:33.390
It's over.

1117
00:56:34.826 --> 00:56:37.089
No, it's not over...

1118
00:56:37.132 --> 00:56:40.179
because you obviously
haven't forgiven me either.

1119
00:56:40.222 --> 00:56:41.223
Look, we have been
on top of each other

1120
00:56:41.267 --> 00:56:42.703
non-stop since we left!

1121
00:56:42.834 --> 00:56:44.052
Can we just
give this a break?

1122
00:56:44.052 --> 00:56:45.227
Okay.

1123
00:56:47.186 --> 00:56:49.101
I hear you.
I'm leaving.

1124
00:56:49.144 --> 00:56:49.884
Wait a minute.
What-What are you doing?

1125
00:56:49.928 --> 00:56:51.756
I get it, John!

1126
00:56:51.843 --> 00:56:53.410
Karen, I didn't say
you had to leave.

1127
00:56:55.063 --> 00:56:55.934
Karen!

1128
00:57:03.898 --> 00:57:05.683
What?

1129
00:57:05.726 --> 00:57:07.293
What do you think about us
never going to Aruba again?

1130
00:57:09.077 --> 00:57:10.209
Deal.

1131
00:57:13.125 --> 00:57:14.169
Hey, hon'.

1132
00:57:14.213 --> 00:57:15.736
Hey.

1133
00:57:17.085 --> 00:57:18.130
How are you?

1134
00:57:30.621 --> 00:57:32.971
Is there
something we need to talk about?

1135
00:57:35.016 --> 00:57:36.888
I don't know.

1136
00:57:36.931 --> 00:57:40.065
You don't know what?

1137
00:57:44.809 --> 00:57:47.594
You know,
I-I don't need this.

1138
00:57:47.638 --> 00:57:50.379
You want to be
a little bit more specific?

1139
00:57:50.423 --> 00:57:51.642
Yeah. I'm sick of the arguing.

1140
00:57:51.642 --> 00:57:55.123
I'm not so quick to jump
back into the...

1141
00:57:55.167 --> 00:57:57.082
tch, the lovey-dovey,
as you are.

1142
00:57:58.649 --> 00:58:00.825
You know, I've been
trying to get over this hump.

1143
00:58:00.868 --> 00:58:03.523
You-You say you don't want
to fight weekly, and...

1144
00:58:03.567 --> 00:58:05.830
and then you're so quick
to fly off the handle.

1145
00:58:07.222 --> 00:58:08.659
It really feels like

1146
00:58:08.789 --> 00:58:10.617
you're setting me up
to fail here, John.

1147
00:58:15.187 --> 00:58:17.189
You know...

1148
00:58:17.276 --> 00:58:18.886
it's late.

1149
00:58:18.886 --> 00:58:20.235
We're both tired.

1150
00:58:20.279 --> 00:58:22.281
Let's just, uh, go to bed,

1151
00:58:22.324 --> 00:58:24.152
and...

1152
00:58:24.239 --> 00:58:27.329
we can forget about this
for now.

1153
00:58:39.864 --> 00:58:42.344
Mm. What time is it?

1154
00:58:42.388 --> 00:58:45.434
It's time to get going.

1155
00:58:45.478 --> 00:58:48.220
No. Let's just stay in bed
a little bit longer.

1156
00:58:48.263 --> 00:58:50.091
No. I-I gotta go.

1157
00:58:50.091 --> 00:58:51.528
Oh, come on.

1158
00:58:51.615 --> 00:58:54.313
Let's start the day off
in a good mood.

1159
00:58:55.532 --> 00:58:56.228
John!

1160
00:58:59.448 --> 00:59:01.450
What the hell?

1161
00:59:04.976 --> 00:59:06.499
Hey.

1162
00:59:06.543 --> 00:59:07.935
John, you really hurt me
this time.

1163
00:59:07.979 --> 00:59:09.154
Just tell me

1164
00:59:09.197 --> 00:59:10.372
if you're interested
in someone else.

1165
00:59:10.416 --> 00:59:11.286
I can't think
of any other reason why

1166
00:59:11.373 --> 00:59:12.331
you're being this way.

1167
00:59:12.418 --> 00:59:14.376
I'm not.
Look--

1168
00:59:14.463 --> 00:59:15.943
I'm about
to pick up the kids.

1169
00:59:16.030 --> 00:59:17.597
I'm not in the mood
to talk right now. Can I--

1170
00:59:17.641 --> 00:59:19.164
Oh, okay, so you're not
into it anymore.

1171
00:59:19.207 --> 00:59:20.165
I gotta go.

1172
00:59:23.995 --> 00:59:25.257
You know, the other day,

1173
00:59:25.344 --> 00:59:26.563
I was trying to talk to you
about our future,

1174
00:59:26.606 --> 00:59:27.868
and you were just, like,

1175
00:59:27.955 --> 00:59:29.566
"Yeah. Yeah, okay,
what about it?"

1176
00:59:29.609 --> 00:59:32.046
Not how it went down,
but okay.

1177
00:59:32.090 --> 00:59:33.613
So you're really
not into this anymore?

1178
00:59:33.700 --> 00:59:35.093
No, I am just sick

1179
00:59:35.136 --> 00:59:37.443
of fighting and arguing
all the time. Like--

1180
00:59:37.486 --> 00:59:39.010
Look, I gotta go.

1181
00:59:44.929 --> 00:59:46.757
Oh, my God!
Just stop calling me.

1182
00:59:48.889 --> 00:59:49.890
Oh, my God.

1183
00:59:54.852 --> 00:59:57.245
John! Call me back!

1184
01:00:09.388 --> 01:00:10.563
Residents of Canton

1185
01:00:10.650 --> 01:00:11.869
are under a blizzard warning

1186
01:00:11.956 --> 01:00:13.131
and are advised to prepare

1187
01:00:13.218 --> 01:00:15.481
for a dangerous
and historic snowstorm

1188
01:00:15.568 --> 01:00:17.265
with life-threatening
conditions.

1189
01:00:17.309 --> 01:00:18.832
Heavy snowfall
and strong winds...

1190
01:00:18.876 --> 01:00:20.138
Maybe just stay
at home tonight, Karen.

1191
01:00:20.181 --> 01:00:22.140
They're saying it's gonna
come down pretty hard.

1192
01:00:22.183 --> 01:00:24.708
Nah, the heavy stuff's
not coming till later.

1193
01:00:24.795 --> 01:00:26.405
Ah, it's just that
when they say "blizzard,"

1194
01:00:26.492 --> 01:00:27.754
it doesn't mean "flurries."

1195
01:00:27.798 --> 01:00:29.756
Look--

1196
01:00:29.800 --> 01:00:31.540
John and I,
we've been fighting all day.

1197
01:00:31.584 --> 01:00:33.760
I think it's really important
for me to see him tonight, Dad.

1198
01:00:33.847 --> 01:00:36.197
Besides, if I get snowed in,

1199
01:00:36.328 --> 01:00:38.243
I'd rather be up there
with John and the kids,

1200
01:00:38.286 --> 01:00:39.679
than here by myself.

1201
01:00:39.723 --> 01:00:41.768
Plus, we always have fun
on the weekends.

1202
01:00:41.812 --> 01:00:44.510
Well, sweetheart,
just be careful.

1203
01:00:44.553 --> 01:00:46.251
Don't worry.

1204
01:00:46.294 --> 01:00:47.905
Nothing bad's gonna happen.

1205
01:01:01.135 --> 01:01:02.615
Okay.

1206
01:01:02.659 --> 01:01:05.313
Okay.

1207
01:01:05.357 --> 01:01:08.012
I'll come for a drink.

1208
01:01:17.282 --> 01:01:18.805
Hey, can I get a vodka soda?

1209
01:01:26.595 --> 01:01:28.075
Can I get one more?

1210
01:01:28.119 --> 01:01:29.990
That's drink number four...

1211
01:01:30.034 --> 01:01:31.383
five...

1212
01:01:31.470 --> 01:01:32.384
six...

1213
01:01:34.473 --> 01:01:35.692
...seven--
seven drinks in total,

1214
01:01:35.735 --> 01:01:37.128
at McCarthy's,

1215
01:01:37.171 --> 01:01:38.695
before the defendant
moved on to the Waterfall,

1216
01:01:38.738 --> 01:01:39.870
where she kept drinking.

1217
01:01:41.610 --> 01:01:44.135
And then...
she got behind the wheel,

1218
01:01:44.178 --> 01:01:47.747
and drove to 34 Fairview
with John O'Keefe.

1219
01:01:57.888 --> 01:02:00.455
Free Karen Read!
Free Karen Read!

1220
01:02:00.542 --> 01:02:02.588
Free Karen Read!

1221
01:02:02.631 --> 01:02:04.982
Free Karen Read!
Free Karen Read!

1222
01:02:06.853 --> 01:02:09.508
I didn't think anybody
would be paying attention

1223
01:02:09.508 --> 01:02:11.379
when I said
my favorite color was pink.

1224
01:02:11.423 --> 01:02:14.731
Free Karen Read!
Free Karen Read!

1225
01:02:17.516 --> 01:02:18.952
I'm handing you a document.

1226
01:02:18.996 --> 01:02:19.997
Do you recognize it?

1227
01:02:20.040 --> 01:02:21.868
Yes.

1228
01:02:21.912 --> 01:02:24.697
And what do
you recognize it to be?

1229
01:02:24.784 --> 01:02:27.308
It's a text message thread

1230
01:02:27.352 --> 01:02:29.484
labeled
"Proctor's Friends."

1231
01:02:29.528 --> 01:02:32.313
So these all came from me.

1232
01:02:32.400 --> 01:02:34.272
"From all accounts,
he didn't do anything wrong.

1233
01:02:34.359 --> 01:02:36.796
She's a whack-job

1234
01:02:36.883 --> 01:02:38.450
C-U--"

1235
01:02:38.537 --> 01:02:40.147
Objection.

1236
01:02:40.234 --> 01:02:41.409
So don't spell it.

1237
01:02:41.453 --> 01:02:43.020
You have to--

1238
01:02:43.107 --> 01:02:46.719
This is... These are
your words, Trooper Proctor?

1239
01:02:46.763 --> 01:02:48.503
Yes, your Honor.

1240
01:02:48.547 --> 01:02:49.722
So go ahead and say them.

1241
01:02:52.116 --> 01:02:53.421
"She's a whack-job c* *."

1242
01:02:55.510 --> 01:02:57.382
"She's a babe.

1243
01:02:57.425 --> 01:02:59.210
Weird Fall River accent, though.

1244
01:02:59.253 --> 01:03:01.168
No ass."

1245
01:03:01.212 --> 01:03:03.214
These are
unprofessional comments,

1246
01:03:03.257 --> 01:03:04.781
but they absolutely
do not detract

1247
01:03:04.824 --> 01:03:06.913
from the integrity
of the investigation,

1248
01:03:07.000 --> 01:03:09.916
or the facts
and the evidence of it.

1249
01:03:09.960 --> 01:03:12.005
Sir...

1250
01:03:12.049 --> 01:03:14.616
how did you refer to Miss Read
in your text exchange

1251
01:03:14.660 --> 01:03:15.879
when you informed them

1252
01:03:15.879 --> 01:03:17.402
that you were going
through her phone?

1253
01:03:17.445 --> 01:03:19.926
I used regrettable language.

1254
01:03:20.013 --> 01:03:23.669
I said that I was going through
his "retarded" client's phone.

1255
01:03:23.712 --> 01:03:25.845
And who were you
referring to as "retarded"?

1256
01:03:25.889 --> 01:03:27.499
Ms. Read.

1257
01:03:27.542 --> 01:03:29.196
So, the person
that you were investigating,

1258
01:03:29.240 --> 01:03:30.545
you referred to--

1259
01:03:30.545 --> 01:03:32.156
to your bosses--
as "retarded," correct?

1260
01:03:32.243 --> 01:03:34.114
Again, poor language
on my part.

1261
01:03:34.158 --> 01:03:35.420
"Poor language"
is one way to put it.

1262
01:03:35.463 --> 01:03:36.682
"Completely offensive"
is another way to put it.

1263
01:03:36.725 --> 01:03:38.162
Then, what did you write,

1264
01:03:38.205 --> 01:03:39.511
after you talked about
going through her phone?

1265
01:03:42.122 --> 01:03:44.298
"No nudes so far."

1266
01:03:44.342 --> 01:03:45.996
So you were looking
for naked photographs

1267
01:03:46.039 --> 01:03:47.301
of Miss Read, correct?

1268
01:03:47.345 --> 01:03:48.912
No, not correct.

1269
01:03:48.955 --> 01:03:50.652
Let me ask you a question.

1270
01:03:50.696 --> 01:03:52.785
Have you ever looked
for naked photographs

1271
01:03:52.829 --> 01:03:54.961
of male suspects
you were investigating?

1272
01:03:55.048 --> 01:03:57.616
I don't look for naked photos
on anyone's phones.

1273
01:03:57.703 --> 01:03:59.444
But you just said

1274
01:03:59.487 --> 01:04:01.620
you were looking for nudes
of Miss Read.

1275
01:04:01.663 --> 01:04:05.058
Like I said, Mr. Jackson--
it was an inappropriate joke.

1276
01:04:05.189 --> 01:04:06.668
So, you weren't so much

1277
01:04:06.712 --> 01:04:08.540
objectively investigating
Karen Read

1278
01:04:08.583 --> 01:04:10.803
as objectifying,
correct?

1279
01:04:12.718 --> 01:04:14.807
Before you even
went into the house,

1280
01:04:14.851 --> 01:04:16.635
having interviewed
only three folks,

1281
01:04:16.678 --> 01:04:18.245
you had this case
nice and wrapped up, didn't you?

1282
01:04:18.289 --> 01:04:20.073
Yes.

1283
01:04:20.117 --> 01:04:23.294
Based on the evidence uncovered
by my office that day--

1284
01:04:23.337 --> 01:04:25.818
the one shoe
discovered at the scene,

1285
01:04:25.905 --> 01:04:28.865
the one shoe at the hospital,
Mr. O'Keefe's injuries,

1286
01:04:28.908 --> 01:04:30.605
the broken tail piece
underneath the snow, the--

1287
01:04:30.692 --> 01:04:31.998
No, Trooper Proctor.

1288
01:04:32.042 --> 01:04:33.521
I didn't ask
for your explanation.

1289
01:04:33.565 --> 01:04:35.045
I asked,

1290
01:04:35.045 --> 01:04:36.960
did you, in your mind,
have this case wrapped up?

1291
01:04:38.700 --> 01:04:40.006
Was it cut-and-dry
in your mind?

1292
01:04:40.050 --> 01:04:41.355
Yes.

1293
01:04:41.399 --> 01:04:42.748
Then you indicated,

1294
01:04:42.879 --> 01:04:44.663
"We're gonna put
serious charges on the girl."

1295
01:04:44.706 --> 01:04:47.231
Who were you referring to
as "the girl"?

1296
01:04:47.274 --> 01:04:48.885
The defendant.

1297
01:04:48.928 --> 01:04:50.147
The way
you were going to make it--

1298
01:04:50.234 --> 01:04:51.800
cut and dry, right?

1299
01:04:51.844 --> 01:04:53.541
Pretty simple!
Just pin it on the girl!

1300
01:04:53.585 --> 01:04:55.500
Absolutely not.

1301
01:04:55.587 --> 01:04:57.241
Then what did you write?

1302
01:05:00.157 --> 01:05:01.506
"She's screwed."

1303
01:05:01.593 --> 01:05:02.768
"She's screwed."

1304
01:05:02.899 --> 01:05:06.380
You decided, individually,
Trooper Proctor,

1305
01:05:06.424 --> 01:05:09.122
that you were not only
going to put it on the girl,

1306
01:05:09.209 --> 01:05:10.907
you decided

1307
01:05:10.950 --> 01:05:12.517
you were going to make sure
this case was cut and dried,

1308
01:05:12.560 --> 01:05:14.432
and the way
you were going to do it

1309
01:05:14.519 --> 01:05:17.000
is to make sure
she's "screwed".

1310
01:05:17.043 --> 01:05:18.175
I mean, that's what
you were saying.

1311
01:05:18.262 --> 01:05:19.828
No. No, absolutely not.

1312
01:05:19.872 --> 01:05:22.527
You responded to a text message
from your sister,

1313
01:05:22.570 --> 01:05:23.571
"Hopefully,
she kills herself."

1314
01:05:23.615 --> 01:05:24.659
Correct?

1315
01:05:24.659 --> 01:05:26.792
It was a figure of speech.

1316
01:05:26.835 --> 01:05:28.881
You believed,
Trooper Proctor,

1317
01:05:28.925 --> 01:05:30.535
that your life
would be much easier

1318
01:05:30.622 --> 01:05:32.493
if Karen Read was just dead.

1319
01:05:32.537 --> 01:05:34.539
No. No, um... no.

1320
01:05:34.582 --> 01:05:36.933
Like I said,
it was a figure of speech.

1321
01:05:36.976 --> 01:05:38.499
My emotions got the best of me,
based on, you know,

1322
01:05:38.543 --> 01:05:41.894
the fact that Ms. Read
hit Mr. O'Keefe with her vehicle

1323
01:05:41.981 --> 01:05:43.417
and left him to die
on the side of the road.

1324
01:05:43.461 --> 01:05:45.158
So my emotions
got the best of me

1325
01:05:45.202 --> 01:05:47.987
with that figure of speech.

1326
01:05:48.031 --> 01:05:50.294
Well, let's talk about
that "figure of speech."

1327
01:05:50.337 --> 01:05:52.774
During the course
of your investigation,

1328
01:05:52.818 --> 01:05:55.821
your figures of speech
include the following...

1329
01:05:55.908 --> 01:05:57.214
"She's a bitch--"

1330
01:05:57.257 --> 01:05:59.956
...a "whack-job,"
a "retard."

1331
01:05:59.999 --> 01:06:01.087
"No ass."

1332
01:06:01.131 --> 01:06:03.611
"She's screwed"--
according to you--

1333
01:06:03.655 --> 01:06:04.917
and "Screw her."

1334
01:06:04.961 --> 01:06:05.962
Correct?

1335
01:06:06.049 --> 01:06:07.833
Correct.

1336
01:06:10.053 --> 01:06:13.360
Do you agree,
Trooper Proctor,

1337
01:06:13.404 --> 01:06:15.232
that you have
dehumanized Karen Read

1338
01:06:15.275 --> 01:06:16.581
during the course
of your investigation,

1339
01:06:16.624 --> 01:06:17.974
with comments
and words like this?

1340
01:06:19.584 --> 01:06:22.369
I would say that...

1341
01:06:22.413 --> 01:06:25.807
based off
of that language...

1342
01:06:25.851 --> 01:06:28.114
um...

1343
01:06:28.158 --> 01:06:29.855
yes.

1344
01:06:29.942 --> 01:06:31.074
Because you were
going to make sure

1345
01:06:31.161 --> 01:06:32.989
this case was cut and dry--

1346
01:06:33.032 --> 01:06:34.338
those were your words, right?

1347
01:06:34.381 --> 01:06:35.992
To pin it on "the girl."

1348
01:06:38.037 --> 01:06:39.082
Shame on you, sir.

1349
01:06:39.125 --> 01:06:39.996
Objection!

1350
01:06:41.171 --> 01:06:42.520
...uh, at the Waterfall,

1351
01:06:42.563 --> 01:06:43.477
it seemed like
they were quite lovey-dovey.

1352
01:06:44.913 --> 01:06:46.828
At 12:37:08 a.m.,

1353
01:06:46.872 --> 01:06:48.569
the defendant calls John

1354
01:06:48.613 --> 01:06:50.658
and voicemail number one
is left.

1355
01:06:50.702 --> 01:06:51.833
Miss Gillman,
would you kindly play

1356
01:06:51.920 --> 01:06:54.184
the voicemail
for 12:37:08?

1357
01:06:55.489 --> 01:06:57.361
You know what, John?

1358
01:06:57.404 --> 01:06:58.840
I goddamn hate you!

1359
01:06:58.884 --> 01:07:00.929
Do you hear me?

1360
01:07:00.973 --> 01:07:03.149
I goddamn hate you!

1361
01:07:03.236 --> 01:07:06.109
At 1:17:37 a.m.,
the defendant calls John.

1362
01:07:06.196 --> 01:07:08.285
This is when voicemail six
is left, with voice.

1363
01:07:08.328 --> 01:07:09.982
John, do you hear me?

1364
01:07:10.026 --> 01:07:13.507
You are screwing
another girl!

1365
01:07:13.551 --> 01:07:16.380
What, if anything,
did your brother mention to you

1366
01:07:16.423 --> 01:07:18.295
as far as reasons for...

1367
01:07:18.338 --> 01:07:21.080
an argument
or points of contention?

1368
01:07:21.124 --> 01:07:23.691
Uh, he didn't like it
if, you know,

1369
01:07:23.735 --> 01:07:25.780
she spent a lot of money
on the kids for gifts.

1370
01:07:25.824 --> 01:07:28.696
I know
there were some arguments

1371
01:07:28.740 --> 01:07:30.133
about what she fed 'em--

1372
01:07:30.263 --> 01:07:31.786
whether it was Dunkin' Donuts,
or what have you--

1373
01:07:31.830 --> 01:07:33.658
things along those lines.

1374
01:07:33.658 --> 01:07:35.355
And what, if any,

1375
01:07:35.399 --> 01:07:38.793
occasions, uh,
as far as their arguments,

1376
01:07:38.880 --> 01:07:40.317
or anything like that,

1377
01:07:40.360 --> 01:07:43.102
did you observe,
personally, yourself?

1378
01:07:43.146 --> 01:07:45.104
I witnessed, uh...

1379
01:07:45.148 --> 01:07:47.498
so, they-they had rented
a house down in Cape Cod.

1380
01:07:47.585 --> 01:07:49.717
I witnessed, you know,

1381
01:07:49.761 --> 01:07:52.764
one intense fight
between the two of 'em.

1382
01:07:52.807 --> 01:07:54.287
Tch. Uh...

1383
01:07:54.331 --> 01:07:56.072
it was a verbal argument.

1384
01:07:56.115 --> 01:07:58.683
You know--
typical couples fighting.

1385
01:07:58.726 --> 01:08:01.555
There was alcohol, uh, involved.

1386
01:08:02.730 --> 01:08:04.645
I recall her complaining

1387
01:08:04.689 --> 01:08:05.951
that he wasn't nice to her,

1388
01:08:05.994 --> 01:08:08.127
you know,
something to that effect.

1389
01:08:08.171 --> 01:08:12.305
I was kind of the referee
in that entire situation.

1390
01:08:12.436 --> 01:08:14.525
When you make reference
to the alcohol involved--

1391
01:08:14.568 --> 01:08:15.917
was that one or both?

1392
01:08:15.961 --> 01:08:18.398
Uh, both.

1393
01:08:18.442 --> 01:08:20.922
So, both your brother
and the defendant?

1394
01:08:20.966 --> 01:08:23.099
Correct.

1395
01:08:23.142 --> 01:08:25.275
Do you think
it's standard practice

1396
01:08:25.362 --> 01:08:26.711
to borrow Solo cups
from a neighbor

1397
01:08:26.754 --> 01:08:28.016
to gather evidence?

1398
01:08:28.104 --> 01:08:29.583
Of course not.

1399
01:08:29.627 --> 01:08:32.108
Nothing about this scene
was standard.

1400
01:08:33.500 --> 01:08:35.154
So, after 8 a.m.,

1401
01:08:35.198 --> 01:08:37.635
the crime scene
was completely open, unsecured,

1402
01:08:37.678 --> 01:08:38.940
available to anybody?

1403
01:08:39.027 --> 01:08:40.768
Correct.

1404
01:08:43.423 --> 01:08:46.252
Uh...
so, your expert testimony

1405
01:08:46.296 --> 01:08:47.949
is that John O'Keefe

1406
01:08:48.036 --> 01:08:51.388
was hit by the SUV
and flew 30 feet?

1407
01:08:51.431 --> 01:08:53.303
Would you define "flying"

1408
01:08:53.390 --> 01:08:56.175
as being literally in the air
the whole time or--?

1409
01:08:56.219 --> 01:08:57.742
I-I don't know.
You tell me. You're the expert.

1410
01:08:57.785 --> 01:09:00.875
Well, he was...

1411
01:09:00.962 --> 01:09:02.703
Wh-When we say "projected,"

1412
01:09:02.747 --> 01:09:04.966
we mean he gets projected,

1413
01:09:05.010 --> 01:09:07.621
and then they-they usually
have a landing phase,

1414
01:09:07.665 --> 01:09:09.667
and then they land,

1415
01:09:09.710 --> 01:09:13.236
or they usually roll or tumble
to final rest.

1416
01:09:15.063 --> 01:09:17.240
If struck by a vehicle
going 24 miles per hour,

1417
01:09:17.327 --> 01:09:20.721
I'd expect to see fractures
and deep contusions,

1418
01:09:20.808 --> 01:09:22.767
not just the abrasions
found on the victim's arm.

1419
01:09:22.810 --> 01:09:24.421
Red plastic found in

1420
01:09:24.464 --> 01:09:26.118
the debris scraped
from John O'Keefe's clothing

1421
01:09:26.162 --> 01:09:27.424
were a match

1422
01:09:27.467 --> 01:09:29.948
to the defendant's
damaged tail-light.

1423
01:09:30.035 --> 01:09:32.429
The victim's injuries
don't look remotely consistent

1424
01:09:32.472 --> 01:09:33.604
with being struck
by a vehicle.

1425
01:09:35.040 --> 01:09:37.260
We are here for justice
for John O'Keefe

1426
01:09:37.303 --> 01:09:39.000
and justice for Karen Read,

1427
01:09:39.044 --> 01:09:42.221
because there is no justice
for John O'Keefe

1428
01:09:42.265 --> 01:09:45.529
without justice
for Karen Read!

1429
01:09:47.922 --> 01:09:48.967
As the snow melted,

1430
01:09:49.054 --> 01:09:50.229
more and more pieces
of tail-light

1431
01:09:50.273 --> 01:09:51.404
from the defendant's vehicle

1432
01:09:51.448 --> 01:09:53.145
were uncovered
at the scene.

1433
01:09:53.189 --> 01:09:55.974
Sergeant, were you-- were you
able to see the video okay?

1434
01:09:56.017 --> 01:09:57.454
Uh, based on the motion
of the shot

1435
01:09:57.497 --> 01:09:58.498
with the snow falling,

1436
01:09:58.585 --> 01:10:00.239
it appears that
there is movement,

1437
01:10:00.283 --> 01:10:02.067
but, uh, the video
speaks for itself.

1438
01:10:04.200 --> 01:10:05.679
On the ground,

1439
01:10:05.723 --> 01:10:07.986
around the rear of
Mr. O'Keefe's parked vehicle,

1440
01:10:08.073 --> 01:10:09.988
what, if any, red pieces
or anything do you observe?

1441
01:10:10.075 --> 01:10:11.685
Uh, nothing was observed.

1442
01:10:13.948 --> 01:10:15.907
John never went in the house--
it's not a story...

1443
01:10:15.994 --> 01:10:17.604
it's a fact.

1444
01:10:19.302 --> 01:10:21.739
Uh, Mr. O'Keefe's
Apple Health data indicated

1445
01:10:21.782 --> 01:10:23.654
he climbed up, or down,

1446
01:10:23.654 --> 01:10:26.526
three flights of stairs
between 12:21 and 12:24.

1447
01:10:27.919 --> 01:10:29.442
I cross-referenced
Mr. O'Keefe's phone

1448
01:10:29.486 --> 01:10:31.227
and his Apple Watch,

1449
01:10:31.270 --> 01:10:32.880
and the data indicate

1450
01:10:32.924 --> 01:10:37.015
he was still a half-a-mile away
from 34 Fairview at 12:24.

1451
01:10:37.102 --> 01:10:40.497
As I left, I noticed
something out of the ordinary,

1452
01:10:40.584 --> 01:10:45.110
like a black blob,
on the ground by the flagpole.

1453
01:10:45.110 --> 01:10:47.721
It was pretty dark
and snowy.

1454
01:10:49.114 --> 01:10:52.465
I was also intoxicated...
drinking.

1455
01:10:54.641 --> 01:10:56.817
At 2:27 a.m.,

1456
01:10:56.817 --> 01:10:57.949
you made a Google search,

1457
01:10:58.036 --> 01:11:00.256
"How long to die in the cold?"
Correct?

1458
01:11:00.343 --> 01:11:03.650
Except, you made a mistake
and typed "H-O-S."

1459
01:11:03.650 --> 01:11:05.173
"Hos long to die in cold?"

1460
01:11:05.261 --> 01:11:07.001
I made that search,

1461
01:11:07.088 --> 01:11:08.481
but I made it in the morning
after 6 a.m.,

1462
01:11:08.525 --> 01:11:09.613
at your client's request.

1463
01:11:11.179 --> 01:11:13.573
I opened up a search tab
at that time, yes,

1464
01:11:13.617 --> 01:11:14.705
but I was looking
at a basketball team

1465
01:11:14.792 --> 01:11:15.880
for my daughter.

1466
01:11:15.923 --> 01:11:17.055
I didn't make that search

1467
01:11:17.098 --> 01:11:18.883
until right after
we found John.

1468
01:11:18.926 --> 01:11:20.188
Karen screamed at me
to look it up,

1469
01:11:20.232 --> 01:11:21.755
and my hands were shaking.

1470
01:11:21.799 --> 01:11:24.410
Karen was saying,
"Google hypothermia."

1471
01:11:24.454 --> 01:11:26.194
Our analysis showed

1472
01:11:26.238 --> 01:11:29.154
that Ms. McCabe's searches for
"how long to die in the cold"

1473
01:11:29.197 --> 01:11:33.724
were, in fact, conducted
at 6:23 and 6:24 a.m.

1474
01:11:34.899 --> 01:11:36.248
Ms. McCabe, the records show

1475
01:11:36.292 --> 01:11:37.815
you made that search
at 2:27 a.m.

1476
01:11:37.815 --> 01:11:39.033
I made that search
after 6 a.m.

1477
01:11:39.077 --> 01:11:40.470
at your client's request.

1478
01:11:41.949 --> 01:11:43.168
She kept saying,
"I hit him.

1479
01:11:43.299 --> 01:11:45.083
I hit him.
Oh, my God, I hit him."

1480
01:11:45.126 --> 01:11:46.911
"I hit him"?

1481
01:11:46.954 --> 01:11:48.782
No, I didn't hear that part.

1482
01:11:48.826 --> 01:11:49.827
So you're telling me
you actually

1483
01:11:49.914 --> 01:11:51.481
heard what she said
in a snowstorm?

1484
01:11:51.568 --> 01:11:54.484
I can tell you today
with 100% clarity,

1485
01:11:54.571 --> 01:11:57.269
she said, "I hit him,
I hit him, I hit him."

1486
01:11:57.313 --> 01:11:59.053
Mr. Loughran,

1487
01:11:59.097 --> 01:12:03.188
when you drove your snowplow
past 34 Fairview that night,

1488
01:12:03.231 --> 01:12:07.235
how much of the front lawn area
did your headlights illuminate?

1489
01:12:07.279 --> 01:12:09.150
The entire front lawn.

1490
01:12:09.194 --> 01:12:11.979
And, at that hour,
at 2:45 in the morning--

1491
01:12:12.023 --> 01:12:14.721
did you see anything
in that front-lawn area,

1492
01:12:14.808 --> 01:12:16.810
near the flagpole?

1493
01:12:16.854 --> 01:12:18.508
I saw nothing.

1494
01:12:18.551 --> 01:12:20.074
A body?

1495
01:12:20.161 --> 01:12:22.120
No.

1496
01:12:23.295 --> 01:12:24.340
No further questions.

1497
01:12:29.170 --> 01:12:29.562
Thanks for joining us.

1498
01:12:30.433 --> 01:12:31.695
I'm Chris Tanaka
with a WBZ News update.

1499
01:12:31.695 --> 01:12:34.001
After weeks of testimony
and dozens of witnesses,

1500
01:12:34.045 --> 01:12:36.134
closing arguments
finally said today

1501
01:12:36.177 --> 01:12:37.265
in the Karen Read
murder trial...

1502
01:12:37.309 --> 01:12:40.356
Free Karen Read!
Free Karen Read!

1503
01:12:42.053 --> 01:12:43.184
Last day in court.

1504
01:12:43.228 --> 01:12:45.622
No more "What's next?"

1505
01:12:45.665 --> 01:12:47.450
"What witness is next?"

1506
01:12:47.537 --> 01:12:50.278
"What questions
are you gonna be asking them?"

1507
01:12:50.322 --> 01:12:52.063
I'm glad that part's
over with.

1508
01:12:52.106 --> 01:12:53.978
You're looking at the positive.

1509
01:12:54.021 --> 01:12:56.676
That's good.

1510
01:12:56.720 --> 01:12:58.374
Yeah.

1511
01:12:58.461 --> 01:13:00.637
I woke up this morning,
it just--

1512
01:13:00.724 --> 01:13:02.247
it felt weird.

1513
01:13:02.334 --> 01:13:03.988
It felt weird not knowing
where I'm gonna sleep tonight.

1514
01:13:04.031 --> 01:13:05.685
I could be all alone...

1515
01:13:07.208 --> 01:13:09.559
...in prison.

1516
01:13:17.393 --> 01:13:19.830
Just look the other way.

1517
01:13:19.873 --> 01:13:22.180
That's what they want.

1518
01:13:22.223 --> 01:13:24.704
That's what
they're counting on.

1519
01:13:26.184 --> 01:13:28.578
But the uncanny fact

1520
01:13:28.621 --> 01:13:31.189
is that you have been lied to
in this courtroom,

1521
01:13:31.232 --> 01:13:33.060
and your job

1522
01:13:33.104 --> 01:13:35.323
is to never, ever
look the other way.

1523
01:13:35.411 --> 01:13:39.240
Your singular duty
is to stare down the evidence,

1524
01:13:39.284 --> 01:13:41.591
and do it unflinchingly,

1525
01:13:41.634 --> 01:13:43.201
and do it unwaveringly.

1526
01:13:43.244 --> 01:13:45.116
You are the last line
of defense

1527
01:13:45.203 --> 01:13:47.248
between Karen Read

1528
01:13:47.292 --> 01:13:50.338
and the tyranny of injustice.

1529
01:13:50.426 --> 01:13:52.340
How did we get here?

1530
01:13:52.384 --> 01:13:53.864
Hmm?

1531
01:13:53.951 --> 01:13:55.256
Well, first...

1532
01:13:55.300 --> 01:13:57.607
you build a tall, blue wall...

1533
01:13:57.650 --> 01:13:58.608
but, most importantly...

1534
01:14:00.174 --> 01:14:01.654
...you pick your patsy,

1535
01:14:01.698 --> 01:14:03.090
and you pin it on the girl.

1536
01:14:04.483 --> 01:14:06.398
The question is...

1537
01:14:06.398 --> 01:14:07.965
what will you do
with this moment?

1538
01:14:08.052 --> 01:14:11.534
Ignore the-- the lies,
and the manipulations,

1539
01:14:11.577 --> 01:14:14.450
and the misogyny and the bias,
the lack of evidence?

1540
01:14:14.493 --> 01:14:16.016
Would you ever do that?

1541
01:14:16.060 --> 01:14:17.409
Could you
ever do that?

1542
01:14:17.453 --> 01:14:19.672
Or will you say,
with your verdict,

1543
01:14:19.759 --> 01:14:21.326
"I see the truth"?

1544
01:14:22.632 --> 01:14:24.808
Ladies and gentlemen,

1545
01:14:24.808 --> 01:14:27.463
Karen Read is innocent.

1546
01:14:28.812 --> 01:14:30.378
Do justice

1547
01:14:30.422 --> 01:14:31.989
and find her not guilty.

1548
01:14:37.473 --> 01:14:38.865
"I hit him...

1549
01:14:38.909 --> 01:14:40.171
I hit him,

1550
01:14:40.258 --> 01:14:41.694
I hit him."

1551
01:14:41.738 --> 01:14:44.305
Those were the words
of the defendant.

1552
01:14:44.349 --> 01:14:45.698
"This is all my fault."

1553
01:14:45.829 --> 01:14:47.221
"I did this."

1554
01:14:47.265 --> 01:14:48.571
Those were the words

1555
01:14:48.614 --> 01:14:50.311
that came from
the defendant's mouth

1556
01:14:50.355 --> 01:14:51.965
on January 29th

1557
01:14:52.052 --> 01:14:55.360
while John O'Keefe lay dying...

1558
01:14:55.447 --> 01:14:58.450
on the front lawn
of 34 Fairview Road,

1559
01:14:58.494 --> 01:15:00.104
where the defendant
had left him

1560
01:15:00.147 --> 01:15:02.367
after striking him
with her vehicle

1561
01:15:02.410 --> 01:15:04.804
several hours before,
and then left him there,

1562
01:15:04.891 --> 01:15:05.979
freezing,
in a blizzard.

1563
01:15:06.023 --> 01:15:07.328
Moments later,

1564
01:15:07.372 --> 01:15:08.895
the defendant leaves
that voicemail,

1565
01:15:08.939 --> 01:15:10.201
seething with rage.

1566
01:15:10.288 --> 01:15:14.118
Screaming,
"John, I hate you!"

1567
01:15:14.161 --> 01:15:16.860
"John, I'm here with your kids.
Nobody knows where you are."

1568
01:15:16.903 --> 01:15:19.645
Only somebody did know
where Mr. O'Keefe was.

1569
01:15:19.689 --> 01:15:21.473
The defendant knew
exactly where he was,

1570
01:15:21.517 --> 01:15:23.257
because she had
driven him there.

1571
01:15:23.301 --> 01:15:24.911
She struck him there,

1572
01:15:24.998 --> 01:15:27.087
and she left him there to die.

1573
01:15:27.174 --> 01:15:28.480
In the morning,

1574
01:15:28.567 --> 01:15:30.613
she doesn't ask,
"Is he okay?"

1575
01:15:30.700 --> 01:15:32.136
"Is he gonna be okay?"

1576
01:15:32.179 --> 01:15:33.746
"How is he?"

1577
01:15:33.790 --> 01:15:35.922
Any sort of questions
about his medical condition.

1578
01:15:35.966 --> 01:15:37.184
Just, "Is he dead?"

1579
01:15:37.271 --> 01:15:41.275
Over and over
and over again.

1580
01:15:41.319 --> 01:15:42.842
Facts are stubborn things,

1581
01:15:42.886 --> 01:15:44.583
and whatever may be
our wishes,

1582
01:15:44.670 --> 01:15:46.542
our inclinations,

1583
01:15:46.585 --> 01:15:49.414
or the dictates
of our passions...

1584
01:15:49.501 --> 01:15:51.808
they cannot alter

1585
01:15:51.895 --> 01:15:53.636
the state of the facts

1586
01:15:53.679 --> 01:15:54.985
and of the evidence,

1587
01:15:55.028 --> 01:15:56.726
and what the facts
and the evidence

1588
01:15:56.769 --> 01:15:58.554
demonstrate here

1589
01:15:58.597 --> 01:16:00.164
is that the defendant

1590
01:16:00.251 --> 01:16:04.298
drove her car in reverse...

1591
01:16:04.385 --> 01:16:06.257
struck Mr. O'Keefe,

1592
01:16:06.300 --> 01:16:08.651
causing those catastrophic
brain injuries,

1593
01:16:08.694 --> 01:16:12.829
leaving him incapacitated,
and freezing to death.

1594
01:16:22.534 --> 01:16:24.536
You could really
sense the anxiety

1595
01:16:24.623 --> 01:16:26.451
from Karen Read's supporters,

1596
01:16:26.494 --> 01:16:27.931
which is a different story
from yesterday

1597
01:16:27.974 --> 01:16:29.149
and the day before,

1598
01:16:29.193 --> 01:16:31.630
when they were
excited and confident.

1599
01:16:31.674 --> 01:16:33.545
Today, many of them told me
they are nervous,

1600
01:16:33.632 --> 01:16:35.286
and expected a verdict by now.

1601
01:16:37.331 --> 01:16:39.116
I should've listened to you.

1602
01:16:39.246 --> 01:16:41.161
I shouldn't have
gone out that night.

1603
01:16:41.205 --> 01:16:42.902
Why did I go out that night?

1604
01:16:50.606 --> 01:16:52.129
Look.

1605
01:16:53.478 --> 01:16:56.307
I know this has been hell,

1606
01:16:56.307 --> 01:17:00.137
but I can't tell you
how proud I am of you.

1607
01:17:00.224 --> 01:17:03.183
There's so many women
that identify with you,

1608
01:17:03.183 --> 01:17:06.404
because they know what it's like
to be objectified,

1609
01:17:06.534 --> 01:17:08.928
dehumanized... victimized.

1610
01:17:11.104 --> 01:17:12.845
With you...

1611
01:17:12.932 --> 01:17:15.456
they see strength,

1612
01:17:15.500 --> 01:17:17.633
and the courage to fight back.

1613
01:17:21.071 --> 01:17:22.681
It's hard to describe,

1614
01:17:22.725 --> 01:17:25.858
if you're not standing
right here at the courthouse--

1615
01:17:25.902 --> 01:17:28.687
as the jury goes into
its fifth day of deliberation,

1616
01:17:28.731 --> 01:17:30.994
the feeling in the air
is just different.

1617
01:17:36.303 --> 01:17:38.175
I'll take a mistrial, okay?

1618
01:17:38.218 --> 01:17:42.135
You can keep me in limbo
for 10 years, just...

1619
01:17:42.179 --> 01:17:44.007
just, please...

1620
01:17:44.094 --> 01:17:46.487
oh, God, please let me
go home tonight.

1621
01:17:46.531 --> 01:17:49.142
Karen... hey.

1622
01:17:49.186 --> 01:17:50.622
Just go back to the evidence.

1623
01:17:50.666 --> 01:17:52.145
Obviously, we--

1624
01:17:54.191 --> 01:17:57.542
...we were all hoping
for a faster, quicker verdict,

1625
01:17:57.585 --> 01:17:59.239
but I can't imagine
12 jurors would ever say

1626
01:17:59.283 --> 01:18:00.545
you're guilty of anything.

1627
01:18:05.376 --> 01:18:08.161
I mean, what if they don't even
let me hug my father

1628
01:18:08.205 --> 01:18:09.685
before they put me
in handcuffs?

1629
01:18:13.297 --> 01:18:15.038
It's not gonna happen.

1630
01:18:18.824 --> 01:18:20.652
Karen...

1631
01:18:20.696 --> 01:18:22.698
it's amazing

1632
01:18:22.741 --> 01:18:25.875
that it took you until now
to break down like that.

1633
01:18:27.572 --> 01:18:30.357
I mean, that just speaks
to your incredible strength.

1634
01:18:42.239 --> 01:18:43.240
Verdict.

1635
01:18:46.417 --> 01:18:47.897
"Despite our rigorous efforts,

1636
01:18:47.940 --> 01:18:51.378
we continue to find ourselves
at an impasse.

1637
01:18:51.422 --> 01:18:54.425
To continue to deliberate
would be futile

1638
01:18:54.468 --> 01:18:56.775
and only serve
to force us to compromise

1639
01:18:56.819 --> 01:18:58.559
these deeply-held beliefs."

1640
01:18:58.603 --> 01:19:00.953
I'm not going to do
that to you, folks.

1641
01:19:00.997 --> 01:19:03.608
Your service here
is complete.

1642
01:19:03.651 --> 01:19:05.741
I'm declaring a mistrial
in this case.

1643
01:19:08.395 --> 01:19:09.875
Thank you so much
for your service.

1644
01:19:18.536 --> 01:19:19.624
You're not done yet.

1645
01:19:24.368 --> 01:19:26.587
Mr. Lally! Will
the Commonwealth retry the case?

1646
01:19:37.685 --> 01:19:39.470
This is what happens

1647
01:19:39.513 --> 01:19:41.777
when you bring false charges
to an innocent person.

1648
01:19:44.214 --> 01:19:45.563
No matter how long it takes,

1649
01:19:45.606 --> 01:19:47.347
no matter how long
they keep trying,

1650
01:19:47.391 --> 01:19:50.133
we will not stop fighting.

1651
01:19:51.177 --> 01:19:52.135
We have no quit.

1652
01:19:59.533 --> 01:20:01.274
You're attacking the family

1653
01:20:01.318 --> 01:20:02.885
of an innocent man
who was killed!

1654
01:20:02.928 --> 01:20:04.538
What's the matter
with you people?

1655
01:20:04.625 --> 01:20:06.758
Look at 'em--

1656
01:20:06.758 --> 01:20:08.107
it's like the Super Bowl,
Mardi Gras,

1657
01:20:08.151 --> 01:20:10.153
and
Days of Our Lives,
all rolled into one.

1658
01:20:10.240 --> 01:20:12.198
You think these people care
what the truth is?

1659
01:20:12.285 --> 01:20:14.113
They're just here to watch
"The Karen Read Show."

1660
01:20:16.289 --> 01:20:18.683
A mistrial is not justice.

1661
01:20:18.726 --> 01:20:20.380
I don't think
anybody thinks it is.

1662
01:20:20.424 --> 01:20:22.730
Yeah, well, it's better
than going to jail, I guess.

1663
01:20:22.818 --> 01:20:25.168
Well, justice is what we need,

1664
01:20:25.211 --> 01:20:26.909
and justice is not

1665
01:20:26.952 --> 01:20:28.345
you walking
out of that courtroom--

1666
01:20:28.432 --> 01:20:30.956
it's you
not being charged anymore.

1667
01:20:31.000 --> 01:20:31.870
Yeah, well,
I'd rather go to jail

1668
01:20:31.957 --> 01:20:33.393
before I plea out.

1669
01:20:33.437 --> 01:20:35.482
I will never give them
that win.

1670
01:20:38.921 --> 01:20:40.009
Hey, Dad.

1671
01:20:40.052 --> 01:20:42.315
No, I didn't.

1672
01:20:42.359 --> 01:20:43.534
What's going on?

1673
01:20:46.798 --> 01:20:47.712
They're gonna retry it.

1674
01:20:52.586 --> 01:20:53.674
How can the defense lie
like that?

1675
01:20:53.718 --> 01:20:55.372
No way she did it!

1676
01:20:55.415 --> 01:20:56.286
The more evidence I see,
the less I believe.

1677
01:20:57.853 --> 01:20:59.202
Closing arguments today

1678
01:20:59.245 --> 01:21:01.769
at the retrial
of the Karen Read murder case.

1679
01:21:01.813 --> 01:21:03.728
It's been
a year since her first trial.

1680
01:21:03.771 --> 01:21:05.295
Do you think she'll get
an acquittal this go 'round?

1681
01:21:05.295 --> 01:21:07.471
No doubt in my mind.
Karen Read is innocent!

1682
01:21:07.514 --> 01:21:09.952
There was no collision.

1683
01:21:10.039 --> 01:21:11.344
There was
no collision.

1684
01:21:11.388 --> 01:21:13.390
There was... no... collision.

1685
01:21:13.433 --> 01:21:15.827
Stare down injustice.

1686
01:21:17.133 --> 01:21:19.744
You are the last line of defense

1687
01:21:19.787 --> 01:21:22.051
between an innocent woman

1688
01:21:22.138 --> 01:21:24.270
and a system
that tried mightily

1689
01:21:24.357 --> 01:21:26.055
to bury the truth.

1690
01:21:26.098 --> 01:21:29.319
The Commonwealth has
to prove every charge

1691
01:21:29.406 --> 01:21:30.842
beyond a reasonable doubt--

1692
01:21:30.886 --> 01:21:33.410
to an unshakable
moral certainty!

1693
01:21:33.497 --> 01:21:35.412
No officer
ever heard Karen Read say,

1694
01:21:35.499 --> 01:21:36.892
"I hit him."

1695
01:21:36.935 --> 01:21:39.198
It's not in a single
police report! Nowhere!

1696
01:21:39.285 --> 01:21:41.418
The fact is,
there was no collision.

1697
01:21:41.461 --> 01:21:44.029
A car didn't kill John O'Keefe,

1698
01:21:44.116 --> 01:21:46.205
and Karen Read
is an innocent woman.

1699
01:21:46.249 --> 01:21:47.728
Find Karen Read not guilty...

1700
01:21:47.772 --> 01:21:50.122
not guilty...

1701
01:21:50.122 --> 01:21:51.907
not guilty.

1702
01:21:54.518 --> 01:21:56.302
Karen Read was drunk.

1703
01:21:56.346 --> 01:21:57.825
She hit him,

1704
01:21:57.869 --> 01:21:59.392
and she left him to die.

1705
01:21:59.436 --> 01:22:00.698
John didn't go into any house.

1706
01:22:00.741 --> 01:22:02.526
He couldn't.

1707
01:22:02.613 --> 01:22:04.397
His phone never moved again.

1708
01:22:04.484 --> 01:22:07.052
She leaves him a voicemail--
"Nobody knows where you are."

1709
01:22:07.096 --> 01:22:08.532
Panic.

1710
01:22:08.575 --> 01:22:10.621
Drunken denial is setting in.

1711
01:22:10.621 --> 01:22:12.579
They were fighting.

1712
01:22:12.623 --> 01:22:14.320
She got drunk,

1713
01:22:14.364 --> 01:22:15.669
she hit him,

1714
01:22:15.713 --> 01:22:17.367
she left him to die--

1715
01:22:17.454 --> 01:22:19.064
simple as that.

1716
01:22:19.108 --> 01:22:21.893
John O'Keefe
was murdered by Karen Read.

1717
01:22:23.677 --> 01:22:26.419
On day four
of jury deliberations

1718
01:22:26.506 --> 01:22:28.508
in the retrial
of Karen Read,

1719
01:22:28.595 --> 01:22:31.207
the mood here
is of increasing concern

1720
01:22:31.294 --> 01:22:33.644
that this trial may end up
just like the last one--

1721
01:22:33.687 --> 01:22:35.124
with a mistrial.

1722
01:22:47.136 --> 01:22:49.312
Hello?

1723
01:22:57.842 --> 01:23:01.454
All right, I appreciate
you all getting back here.

1724
01:23:01.454 --> 01:23:03.326
Uh, during the luncheon break,

1725
01:23:03.369 --> 01:23:04.762
I received word

1726
01:23:04.805 --> 01:23:06.503
that the jury
knocked on the door,

1727
01:23:06.590 --> 01:23:07.983
indicating
that they had a verdict,

1728
01:23:08.026 --> 01:23:10.333
but shortly thereafter,
they knocked again...

1729
01:23:10.420 --> 01:23:13.162
and said
that they do not have a verdict.

1730
01:23:15.642 --> 01:23:17.731
So, I would ask everyone
remain in the building

1731
01:23:17.775 --> 01:23:20.473
until the end of the day.

1732
01:23:26.305 --> 01:23:28.351
Ahem.

1733
01:23:29.613 --> 01:23:31.049
We're close.

1734
01:23:31.136 --> 01:23:33.008
It's coming.

1735
01:23:59.338 --> 01:24:01.906
Mr. Foreman,
members of the jury,

1736
01:24:01.949 --> 01:24:03.777
have you agreed
upon a verdict?

1737
01:24:03.821 --> 01:24:05.475
Yes.

1738
01:24:05.518 --> 01:24:06.867
Mr. Foreman,

1739
01:24:06.911 --> 01:24:08.521
in the matter of
Murder in the Second Degree,

1740
01:24:08.565 --> 01:24:10.088
what say you?

1741
01:24:10.175 --> 01:24:11.307
Not guilty.

1742
01:24:12.917 --> 01:24:14.266
Manslaughter

1743
01:24:14.310 --> 01:24:15.876
while operating
under the influence--

1744
01:24:15.920 --> 01:24:17.443
what say you?

1745
01:24:17.530 --> 01:24:18.488
Not guilty.

1746
01:24:24.581 --> 01:24:26.844
Operating
under the influence of liquor

1747
01:24:26.887 --> 01:24:28.411
by operating
a motor vehicle--

1748
01:24:28.454 --> 01:24:30.195
so say you, Mr. Foreman?

1749
01:24:30.239 --> 01:24:31.240
Guilty.

1750
01:24:33.024 --> 01:24:34.417
Leaving the scene

1751
01:24:34.460 --> 01:24:36.158
after an accident
resulting in death--

1752
01:24:36.158 --> 01:24:38.725
not guilty, or guilty?

1753
01:24:43.991 --> 01:24:45.123
Not guilty.

1754
01:25:02.271 --> 01:25:03.707
Honestly, it was
the most emotional experience

1755
01:25:03.750 --> 01:25:05.012
I've ever been part of.

1756
01:25:05.100 --> 01:25:06.971
Uh, I feel
I would be disrespecting

1757
01:25:07.014 --> 01:25:09.930
everything our Founding Fathers
risked their lives for,

1758
01:25:10.017 --> 01:25:11.541
if I wasn't out there
fighting for Karen.

1759
01:25:11.628 --> 01:25:12.977
In a statement,

1760
01:25:13.020 --> 01:25:14.935
John O'Keefe's family
called the verdict

1761
01:25:14.979 --> 01:25:16.894
a "devastating miscarriage
of justice".

1762
01:25:19.549 --> 01:25:22.117
You know, I've been preparing
for this for a long time--

1763
01:25:22.160 --> 01:25:24.815
both the worst and the best,
and I'm-I'm...

1764
01:25:24.858 --> 01:25:27.165
I'm so happy
that it turned out for the best.

1765
01:25:45.096 --> 01:25:47.446
I just want to say two things.

1766
01:25:49.405 --> 01:25:52.495
Number one, is I couldn't
be standing here today

1767
01:25:52.538 --> 01:25:55.411
if it wasn't for
these amazing supporters,

1768
01:25:55.454 --> 01:25:59.110
who've supported me,
and my team,

1769
01:25:59.154 --> 01:26:00.459
financially,

1770
01:26:00.546 --> 01:26:03.070
and more importantly,
emotionally,

1771
01:26:03.158 --> 01:26:05.290
for almost four years.

1772
01:26:05.334 --> 01:26:07.988
And the second thing
I want to say

1773
01:26:08.032 --> 01:26:10.643
is that no one
has fought harder for justice

1774
01:26:10.687 --> 01:26:12.123
for John O'Keefe

1775
01:26:12.167 --> 01:26:14.995
than I have--
than I have, and my team.

1776
01:26:16.083 --> 01:26:18.825
Thank you. Thank you.

1777
01:26:24.614 --> 01:26:26.006
I remember everything.

1778
01:26:27.356 --> 01:26:30.141
I said,

1779
01:26:30.228 --> 01:26:31.273
"Could I have hit him?"

1780
01:26:33.623 --> 01:26:35.320
"Did I hit him?"